My email:
Before we parted ways last you challenged me to find information on people
wrongly disfellowshipped. Here is some information that might help you answer
the question of "Has the Watchtower ever wrongly disfellowshipped members?"
Attached is an image that explains the evolution of the Watchtower explanation
of Matthew 24:34 which is the "this generation" prophecy that Jesus referred to.
Now let me give you a scenario:
Lets say someone believes that the Generation Jesus was referring to was
connected to 1914 in some way, which is what they have been taught since they
were a child. The Watchtower would agree with that person's assertion UNTIL 1995
where they abolished the doctrine and connected "this generation" to a general
"wicked people of the earth" explanation. Many people strongly disagreed with
the Society on this change and could not wrap their head around the explanation.
If these people that were voicing their concern on the senselessness of the new
explanation did not change their view to the new teaching they would be DF'ed
for Apostasy.
Fair enough. But the problem arises come 2010 when the "this generation"
explanation went through it's 6th doctrinal reform and was AGAIN connected to
the 1914 date, of which would validate the members that were DF'ed for Apostasy
many years earlier.
This is just food for thought and information on the question you gave me at
Caldwell Park. I will cease online communication with you unless you say
otherwise.
Have a good day.
-Alex
His reply:
Are you kidding me? This is all you have?
First, I asked for you to give me a name of a specific real life
individual. Secondly, I asked you to give the circumstances of that
specific individuals disfellowshipping. Thirdly, what steps did they
take that showed repentance before and after the disfellowshipping.
Lastly, what was the reason the brothers within the congregation gave
for the disfellowshipping.
You, just as in our conversation in the park, can actually provide no
facts behind your so called "research". You use ignorant circular
reasoning and you dodge conversation topics once cornered to provide
proof of your "facts" as you call them. I presented to you many
questions as to the reasons for your actions and beliefs that you were
and are unable to answer.
In your email below you provided none of the answers requested just as
in our previous conversation. You exist on hate, bitterness,
vindictiveness, selfishness, haughtiness, pride, blaming of others, and
a need for validation that you will never receive because of your
actions and the way you present yourself. Now both your wife and you are
accusing your extended family of backstabbing you and treating you
wrongly.
I told you to find the truth if it exists as you see it and offer that.
Instead you attack what you don't believe and are offering nothing in
return. By the way, the facts as you have provided regarding the
generations and the Watchtower Society are grossly inaccurate. As is
everything you have offered so far. Alex , you are a fool.
I have told you previously that I personally have no interest in any
form of communication with you. Please do not contact me again.
Thank you,
Whoa nelly!
-Sab