This Forum.....What Benefit is Is thesedays?

by ScoobySnax 69 Replies latest jw friends

  • ScoobySnax
    ScoobySnax

    Firstly .......I don't mean for one minute the end of friendships that may have been cultivated here.....or the "help" that may have been extended to those who needed it.... There are some good people here. But........

    BUT...... How often can the same old topics be bounced about and re-cycled amongst the topic threads here, usually created by the same few, for an imaginary multitude that I just don't see. OK you say many may look in here, and may not comment. I feel sort of sorry for those that may be in that predicament. I think they must see a sort of messed up sort of group full off cliques and rules that they might have tried to escape from. Several posters have posted recently and its a bit pitiful to see the word TROLL bandied about if you're not in the club. Its becoming far too elite.

    I guess its coz I just don't see this mass exodous that keeps being prophesised here, yes one or two drop in, and you are the first to help them out of their former beliefs.....but sometimes its like being on a round-about....A few hardcore members with a peripheral supporting group parroting the same old stuff in support. Are you really helping? Am I? who knows......just every now and then you need to take stock though. Anger can sometimes be healthy....extended though it becomes a problem. The worst is Ridicule for anyone that doesn't quite fit into the new "enlightened" group......that cuts all understanding stone dead, and defeats the whole original purpose of this forum.

    Many will reply saying how this forum helped them, and thats good. But its such a small drop in the ocean.I still feel sorry for those who may need genuine help because they're hurting and just listen from the sidelines.

    This forum needs to concetrate less on its fixation of the WT and how to bring it down and all that childish playground crap, and more on how to help people who might need an ear to hear, in other words less on projecting their own predjudices and anger and more on taking the time to listen. Sometimes most here sound like such a bitter twisted old tiresome group.....believe me. Self Indulgence gets tiresome. Move on.

  • minimus
    minimus

    Obviously, you're entitled to your opinion. I believe the forum does many different things for different people. Some people use this place for discussion, fun or just to catch up with friends. If it benefits a person, then good. If it stops beneffiting a person ,then why come here? Right?

  • ScoobySnax
    ScoobySnax

    Yes Minimus......I think it then becomes JWD-Lite........Increasingly it is like this. More so as time goes on. You know what I mean.

  • minimus
    minimus

    No I don't know what you mean. Please explain. And tell me what YOU would do to make it better.

  • Valis
    Valis

    Perhaps Scooby it is you who needs to move on. If even to another level of realization. Lots of other people here do that...they bring new perspective to old ideas and offer generational understanding that is very important IMO. As well, I think a lot more of us become friends and discuss other things too, but we try not to forget the why of JWD. That means we chime in and add personal perspective and maybe even get some of the more down trodden and pissed off members to a good place. Maybe you don't get that and that's fine too.

    Sincerely,

    District Overbeer

  • ScoobySnax
    ScoobySnax

    Your assertion that in your opinion if it stops benefiting a person....then why come here, is exactly my point. Smacks of all I said above. Of course that opinion is valid until that thread of thought follows as a reply, and way too often its seen here IMHO.

  • SheilaM
  • minimus
    minimus

    Then I say this without any disrespect intended: If you're not happy here, why not just leave? More than a few posters said their good-byes because they felt they outgrew this place.

  • wednesday
    wednesday

    I think he means that there are not enough serious , meanigful and spirited discussions here. If people do get into a heated discussion then name calling ensues and then the mods come in. and then someone gets deleted. Debating is a skill, and is delightful to read. I too misss some of the good debaters, like Francois.

    Remember "Point, Counterpoint" ffom the Old SNL? I still crack up hearing Dan A say"Jane u ignorant slut..."

    The board has changed a lot in past year, we've had a lot of people come and go. It will keep doing that. It's a DB

  • Valis
    Valis

    Oh that is just crap Scooby...the people that leave here or get kicked don't do so because they don't get anything form the site anymore. The leave or get kicked because they are doing more harm than good. Simple to me. Others may leave for personal reasons or ya sometimes they are bored, but that is not something forced or perpetrated upon them. THAT IS PERSONAL CHOICE! You missed my point entirely to suit your needs. You wouldn't be here if this place weren't a resource for you. So you wouldn't likely leave based on such a post.

    Sincerely,

    District Overbeer

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit