Should a christian go to a psychiatrist / psycolog

by MacHislopp 9 Replies latest jw friends

  • MacHislopp
    MacHislopp

    Hello,

    Please read this one:

    " In the past many have feared or distrusted mental care professionals
    (psycologysts and psychiatrists). There is no basis or need for such
    preconceived fear or distrust. " (PCCC p.53)

    and compare with this one…:

    "… As a rule for a Christian to go to a worldly psychiatrist is an
    admission of defeat. It amounts to 'going down to Egypt for help'-
    Isaiah 31:1. …Also, more and more psychiatrist are resorting to
    hypnosis which is a demonic form of worldly wisdom."
    (Awake ! 1960 March 8 p. 27)

    Agape , J.C. MacHislopp

  • Gianluca
    Gianluca

    I think that the author of the publucations you mentioned need to see a psychiatrist!!!
    And so does Fred Hall!!!

    Keep em coming Mac!! I enjoy your posts!!!

    All the best
    Gianluca

  • happytobefree
    happytobefree

    It's strange that anything that would help clear the mind, is condemned by the WTBS.

    Another great post Machisslopp

    Happy to be Free (Me)

  • apostate
    apostate

    What book is PCCC?

    Make Sure of All Things.

  • Gianluca
    Gianluca

    Hi apostate!
    Check out this link and you will have the answer!!
    http://www.freeminds.org/legal/custody.htm
    Best Regards
    Gianluca

  • trevor
    trevor

    Hi MacHislopp,

    It is not clear from your post whether you mean Christins or JWs.

    The idea of therapy is to help the person involved to become aware of the contradictions and unresolved issues in their life. Then the process of change takes place. The essential ingredient is the willingness of the client to make the changes in their belief structure that are necessary to effect an emotional change.

    Before any Witness could successfully go through therapy they would have to be asked if they were prepared to examine their whole life choice and act upon the revelations that good therapy would result in. If the Witness is totally committed to their rigid, unchangeable mindset the result could be a botched job, which will leave them worse off than before.

    Many Witnesses, like all cult members, deny there is anything wrong in their lives until the emotional mind takes over and acts for them. The result is a nervous breakdown, which precipitates the needed changes.

    Witnesses believe that those going to therapy leave the Organisation as a result. It is usually the case that those who go to therapy are usually on their way out anyway and have already realized the need for change.

    Trevor
    .
    .
    .

    Edited by - trevor on 16 March 2001 7:1:27

  • ICHING
    ICHING

    happytobefree

    It's strange that anything that would help clear the mind, is condemned by the WTBS.

    It would be even stranger if the situation was contrary IMHO.

    I-CHING

    Edited by - iching on 16 March 2001 7:11:35

  • apostate
    apostate

    Gianluca

    Thanks for the link. I didn't know about this brochure. And thanks for the rest of you for all your posts and comments.

    My faith in the Watchtower is weakening every day. If I stick around long enough I will write my Letter of Disassociation some day.

    I love the Internet.

  • MacHislopp
    MacHislopp

    Hello again,

    as it was stated few times, even in this
    board, the PCCC booklet shows what kind of
    results you can get, by listening to advice
    on medical field , given by unprofessional,
    unqualified writers...and after one's hear
    about ...brainwashing techniques!!!

    Agape, J.C.MacHislopp

    P.S. Professional and qualified help is for
    everyone who might need it.

  • ICHING
    ICHING

    .

    Edited by - iching on 17 March 2001 22:31:55

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit