Comments You Will Not Hear at the 4-25-04 WT Study (3-15-04)

by blondie 27 Replies latest watchtower bible

  • blondie
    blondie

    Comments You Will Not Hear at the 4-25-04 WT Study (March 15, 2004 issue)

    Review comments will be in black and parentheses ()

    WT quotes

    will be in red and quotes ""

    Quotes from other sources

    will be in blue

    Bold, underlining, highlighting added by reviewer

    "DO THE WORK OF AN EVANGELIZER"

    "You, though , keep your senses in all things, suffer evil , do [the] work of an evangelizer, fully accomplish your ministry . ."?2 Timothy 4:5 (parts in red not quoted in WT)

    "As for you, always be sober-minded, endure suffering, do the work of an evangelist, fulfill your ministry."?2 Timothy 4:5 (English Standard Version)

    www.biblegateway.com /cgi-bin/bible

    Opening Comments

    After 2 articles trying to establish the authority of the WTS as Jesus? representative on earth, now the WTS feels confident in presenting 2 DO MORE articles.

    There are several words/phrases used throughout the article.

    Zealous (9)

    Shares regularly

    Active

    Zeal (2)

    Make?evangelizing their lifetime work

    Happy praisers of Jehovah (not Jesus?)

    Enlarge their share

    Regular and auxiliary pioneers

    Publishers

    Fruitful evangelizers

    Regular participation

    Materialistic temptations

    Keeping busy

    Do the work of an evangelizer in a complete way

    Fully accomplish

    What old role of the congregation book study overseer is re-emphasized and why? What kind of marking is part of the JW witnessing work and how does that harmonize with the new teaching about the separation of the sheep and the goats?

    START OF ARTICLE

    Jehovah?s name

    and purposes are being declared throughout the earth. This is because God?s dedicated people (only JWs) have taken to heart the commission that Jesus Christ gave his followers when he said: "Go ?( therefore) and make disciples of people of all the nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father and of the Son and of the holy spirit, teaching them to observe all the things I have commanded you. ( And, look! I am with YOU all the days until the conclusion of the system of things) "?Matthew 28:19,20.

    Paragraph 2

    Jesus? first-century disciples took that commission seriously. For instance, the apostle Paul urged his fellow Christian overseer Timothy: "Do the work of an evangelizer, fully accomplish your ministry." (2 Timothy 4:5)

    Today, one way an overseer accomplishes his ministry is by being a zealous Kingdom proclaimer, one who shares regularly in the field ministry.

    For example, the Congregation Book Study overseer

    (why is this capitalized? Perhaps because it is a "title"?) has the rewarding privilege of taking the lead in the preaching work and training others.

    Paul

    fulfilled his personal responsibility to declare the good news, and he helped to train others for the ministry.?Acts 20:20; 1 Corinthians 9:16,17.

    Kingdom Ministry 1/99 p. 8 Overseers Taking the Lead?Congregation Book

    Study Conductors

    Zealous Evangelizing: The Congregation Book Study conductor is conscientious about making practical arrangements for all in his group to participate fully in the field ministry. He takes the lead in the evangelizing work, knowing that the regularity, zeal, and enthusiasm he shows for the service will be reflected in the rest of the group. (Col. 4:17; 2 Thess. 3:9) In time, he endeavors to work in service with each member of his group. If we want to sharpen our preaching and teaching skills in the ministry, the Congregation Book Study conductor can help us to attain our goal.?1 Tim. 4:16; 2 Tim. 4:5.

    Kingdom Ministry 6/94

    p. 1 Congregation Book Study Promotes Educational Activities

    The conductor endeavors over the course of time to work personally with each one in his group, giving appropriate encouragement and training

    Kingdom Ministry

    12/78 p. 3 Showing Appreciation for the Congregation Book Study

    Conductors can get to know you better and are in a good position to assist with personal problems, give training in field service and help you with Scriptural questions.

    Zealous Evangelizers of the Past

    Paragraph 3

    The early Christians were known as zealous evangelizers. Consider the evangelizer Philip. He was one of the "seven certified men?full of spirit and wisdom" chosen to carry out the impartial daily distribution of food among the Greek-speaking and the Hebrew-speaking Christian widows in Jerusalem. (Acts 6:1-6) After that special service ended and persecution scattered all except the apostles, Philip went to Samaria. There he declared the good news and was empowered by holy spirit to cast demons and cure lame and paralyzed individuals. Many Samaritans accepted the Kingdom message and were baptized. Hearing about this, the apostles in Jerusalem dispatched the apostles Peter and John to Samaria so that the newly baptized believers might receive holy spirit.?Acts 8:4-17.

    While all received the holy spirit, the WTS teaches that not all early Christians receive the gifts of the holy spirit.

    Insight Book-1 p. 937 Gifts From God

    Performing apparently miraculous works would not in itself prove divine authorization, nor would the inability of God?s servants to perform miracles with the help of God?s spirit cast doubt on the fact that they were being used by him. (Mt 7:21-23) Not every first-century Christian could perform powerful works, heal, speak in tongues, and translate.

    Pictures Page 10

    Philip in the chariot talking to the Ethiopian eunuch with scroll in hand

    Male JW reading scripture to man standing next to his taxi at taxi stand

    Two of Philip?s daughters with scroll in handing talking to a woman in a courtyard

    2 female JWs sharing a brochure with a woman in a public area

    ****do you get the correlation the WTS is trying to make? Where in any history book does it depict the Christians preaching with scrolls in hand?***

    Paragraph 4

    God?s spirit next led Philip to meet the Ethiopian eunuch on the road to Gaza. After Philip?s clear explanation of Isaiah?s prophecy, this "man in power under Candace queen of the Ethiopians" put faith in Jesus Christ and was baptized. (Acts 8:26-38) Philip thereafter went to Ashdod and then to Caesarea, "declaring the good news to all the cities" along the way. (Acts 8:39,40) He surely set a fine example in doing the work of an evangelizer!

    Philip didn?t seem to spend much time in return visits or extensive Bible studies.

    Paragraph 5

    Philip was still active in the ministry in Caesarea some 20 years later. When Paul and Luke stayed in his home, he "had four daughters, virgins, that prophesied." (Acts 21:8-10) They evidently had been well-trained spiritually, had zeal for the ministry, and were even privileged to engage in speaking prophetically. Parental zeal for the ministry can have a fine effect on sons and daughters today, moving them to make zealous evangelizing their lifetime work.

    Evidently is a WTS buzzword meaning the Bible doesn?t say but they will read into the account that Philip studied with his daughters.

    Guilt alert: Parents, if you children don?t reach out to be pioneers or Bethelites, it's because you did not set a good example.

    How does the WTS undercut the privilege of prophesying given to 4 women, Philip?s daughters?

    Insight-2 p. 698 Prophetess

    Prophesying was among the miraculous gifts of the spirit that were granted to the newly formed Christian congregation. Certain Christian women, such as Philip?s four virgin daughters, prophesied under the impulse of God?s holy spirit. (Ac 21:9; 1Co 12:4, 10) This was in fulfillment of Joel 2:28, 29, which foretold that "your sons and your daughters will certainly prophesy." (Ac 2:14-18) Such gift, however, did not remove a woman from subjection to the headship of her husband or to that of men within the Christian congregation; in symbol of her subjection she was to wear a head covering when prophesying (1Co 11:3-6) and was not to act as a teacher within the congregation.?1Ti 2:11-15; 1Co 14:31-35.

    Insight-2 pp. 697-698 Prophet

    There were, of course, certain ones particularly selected, or gifted, to serve as prophets. (1Co 12:4-11, 27-29) Paul himself had the gift of prophesying, yet he is primarily known as an apostle. (Compare Ac 20:22-25; 27:21-26, 31, 34; 1Co 13:2; 14:6.) Those especially designated as prophets, such as Agabus, Judas, and Silas, appear to have been outstanding spokesmen for the Christian congregation, second only to the apostles. (1Co 12:28; Eph 4:11) Like the apostles, they not only served locally but also traveled to different points, gave discourses, and also foretold certain future events. (Ac 11:27, 28; 13:1; 15:22, 30-33; 21:10, 11) As earlier, some Christian women received the gift of prophesying, though always subject to the headship of the male members of the congregation.?Ac 21:9; 1Co 11:3-5.

    Zealous Evangelizers Today

    Paragraph 6

    In his great prophecy pointing to our day and the time of the end (proof???), Jesus Christ declared: "In all the nations the good news has to be preached first." (Mark 13:10) The end would come after the good news had been preached "in all the inhabited earth." (Matthew 24:14)

    But would every individual be contacted? How is the end of the preaching determined?

    w65 9/15 pp. 575-576 Questions from Readers

    Since
    millions of persons in China and other places have never heard the Kingdom message, will these people be preserved through the destruction of Babylon the Great and the war of Armageddon, or perhaps be resurrected later??H.S., U.S.A.

    But some persons, appreciating that millions of people are to be resurrected and given an opportunity to serve God, wonder if the millions of individuals living today who apparently have never heard the Kingdom message preached will be everlastingly destroyed without ever having had a witness about God?s purposes?. So, if it is Jehovah?s will to have this message personally carried to the millions on earth who seemingly have not yet heard it, that will be accomplished. If he chooses, he could see to it that this message is spread in ways that we cannot yet imagine. Jesus did foretell that "this good news of the kingdom will be preached in all the inhabited earth for a witness to all the nations; and then the end will come." (Matt. 24:14) We can rest assured that God will see that the preaching work is done to his satisfaction. After that "the end" comes.

    As Paul and other first-century evangelizers proclaimed the good news, many became believers, and congregations were formed in one place after another throughout the Roman Empire. Elders appointed to serve in these congregations participated with their brothers and sisters in the evangelizing work and extended the preaching activity far and wide.

    How many knew of elders that never went out with their book study group, that were the invisible men? Earlier in this article, book study overseers were "encouraged" by the WTS to train (work with) those in their book study.

    Jehovah?s word went on growing and prevailing in those days, just as it does today because millions of Jehovah?s Witnesses are doing the work of evangelizers. (Acts 19:20) (the evangelistic work of other groups doesn?t count) Have you taken your stand as one of those happy praisers of Jehovah (not Jesus?)?

    HAPPY PRAISERS OF JEHOVAH!!!! Argghh!

    Paragraph 7

    Many present-day Kingdom proclaimers are taking advantage of opportunities to enlarge their share in the evangelizing work.

    DO MORE

    Thousands have entered the missionary field, and hundreds of thousands share in the full-time evangelizing activity as regular and auxiliary pioneers. And what fine work is being done by men, women, and children serving as zealous Kingdom publishers! Indeed, all of Jehovah?s people (where is Jesus?) are enjoying his rich blessings as they serve him shoulder to shoulder as Christian evangelizers.?Zephaniah 3:9.

    Paragraph 8

    God has given Jesus? anointed followers the responsibility to proclaim the good news throughout the earth. At their side in this evangelizing work is the growing number of Christ?s "other sheep." (John 10:16) Prophetically, this life-saving work is likened to putting a mark on the foreheads of those sighing and groaning over the detestable things now taking place. Soon, the wicked will be destroyed (anyone not a JW). Meanwhile, what a privilege it is to carry lifesaving truths to earth?s inhabitants!?Ezekiel 9:4-6,11.

    How can people be marked for salvation or destruction now if the separation work is still future?

    w98 2/1 pp. 18-19 The Other Sheep and the New Covenant

    Marked to survive the great tribulation, its members will be separated for everlasting life when Jesus divides "the sheep" from "the goats."

    Once again the WTS talks out of both sides of their mouth.

    Paragraph 9

    If we have been engaging in the evangelizing work for some time, very likely we can do something to help new ones in the congregation. On occasion, we may be able to have them accompany us in the ministry (good luck). Those who serve as elders will want to do all they can to build fellow believers up spiritually. The fine efforts of humble overseers can do much to help others to be zealous and fruitful evangelizers.?2 Peter 1:5-8.

    Remember earlier, the WTS counseled the book study overseers (elders) to work with those in their book study group. I get the feeling that the elders are not "taking the lead" in the field ministry. Perhaps they feel they are above all that like the "evil slave" in last week?s lesson. "Fruitful" points to the pattern JWs have of doing little door to door and instead pursuing unfruitful return visits.

    Bearing Witness From House to House

    Paragraph 10

    Jesus Christ set his followers an excellent example as an evangelizer.

    Regarding the ministry of Christ and his apostles, God?s Word states: "He went journeying from city to city and from village to village, preaching and declaring the good news of the kingdom of God. And the twelve were with him." (Luke 8:1) What about the apostles themselves? After the outpouring of holy spirit at Pentecost of 33 CE, "every day in the temple and from house to house they continued without let up teaching and declaring the good news about the Christ, Jesus."?Acts 5:42.**

    **See the information below regarding the scripturalness of the "house to house" or "door to door work."

    Point 1?How the WTS has applied Acts 20:20 to visiting the homes of fellow Christians.

    Point 2?How there are no accounts of preaching to people at the front/back doors in the Bible. (Chart from Ray Franz? ICOF book)

    Point 3?How the identical Greek phrase found at Acts 2:46, Acts 5:42 and Acts 20:20 is translated differently.

    Paragraph 11

    Because of his zealous evangelizing work, the apostle Paul could tell Christian elders from Ephesus: "I did not hold back from telling you any of the tings that were profitable nor from teaching you publicly from house to house." When Paul was ?teaching from house to house," was he visiting the homes of fellow worshipers of Jehovah, making shepherding calls on believers? (see point 1 below) No, for he goes on to explain: "I thoroughly bore witness both to Jews and to Greeks about repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus." (Acts 20:20,21) In general, those already dedicated to Jehovah would not need instruction about "repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus." (they might need reminders) Paul trained the Christian elders of Ephesus in the house-to-house ministry while he taught unbelievers about repentance and faith. (can you find an example in the chart reference in point 2?) In doing this, Paul was copying the method established by Jesus (does it say in the Bible that Jesus went from house to house?)

    Paragraph 12

    The house-to-house ministry can be challenging.

    For example, some are offended when we come to their door with the Bible?s message. It is not our desire to offend people.

    Yet, the house-to-house ministry is Scriptural (see points below), and love of God and neighbor motivates us to bear witness in this way. (Mark 12:28-31)

    No, the main motivation is surviving Armageddon and assuring their living forever on a paradise earth. JWs are not motivated to be "fruitful" because they will receive their "reward" whether anyone listens to them or not. If the WTS did not require JWs to record their time and turn it in, how much time do you think they would spend in the house-to house ministry?

    To ?defend and legally establish? our right to preach from house to house, we have presented cases before the courts, including the Supreme Court of the United States. (Philippians 1:7) Almost invariably that court has decided in our favor. Typical is the following verdict:

    Paragraph 13

    "The hand distribution of religious tracts is an age-old form of missionary evangelism?as old as the history of printing presses. It has been a potent force in various religious movements down through the years. This form of evangelism is utilized today, on a large scale by various religious sects whose colporteurs carry the Gospel to thousands upon thousands of homes and seek through personal visitations to win adherents to their faith?.This form of religious activity occupies the same high estate under the First Amendment [to the United States Constitution] as do worship in the churches and preaching from the pulpits."?Murdock v Pennsylvania, 1944.

    It is not that the US government endorses door to door preaching but rather than people have other means to deal with JWs at their door.

    As to the former, an unchallenged ordinance section authorizing residents to post "No Solicitation" signs, coupled with their unquestioned right to refuse to engage in conversation with unwelcome visitors, provides ample protection for unwilling listeners.

    http://supct.law.cornell.edu/supct/html/00-1737.ZS.html

    Why Keep on Preaching?

    Paragraph 14

    There are many reasons to witness from house to house.

    Each time we call on a householder, we try to plant a seed (place a publication) of Scriptural truth (without ever getting out the Bible). By making return visits (at times we know people aren?t home), we seek to water it. And there can be a fine cumulative effect, for Paul wrote: "I planted, Apollos watered, but God kept making it grow." (1 Corinthians 3:6) So let us keep on ?planting and watering,? confident that Jehovah ?will make it grow.?

    Paragraph 15

    We do the work of evangelizers because our lives are at stake.

    Finally, the real reason JWs do the house to house work.

    By preaching we can save ourselves and those who listen to us. (1 Timothy 4:16) If we knew that a person?s life was endangered, would we make only one feeble attempt to help him? Hardly!

    But if our eternal life was not depending on anyone listening?It is the difference between being on salary, being paid regardless of what you produce, or being paid on commission, no sale, no money.

    Since salvation is involved, we make repeated calls at the homes of people. Circumstances keep on changing. Someone who is too busy to listen on one occasion may be willing to hear the Bible?s message at another time. A different member of the family may answer the door and that could lead to a Scriptural discussion.

    Salvation only by works per the WTS. Can a Christian earn everlasting life? Isn?t it "undeserved kindness" in that there is nothing a Christian can do be worthy?

    Paragraph 17

    Foremost among our reasons for witnessing from house to house or engaging in other forms of the Christian ministry is the desire to have a share making known Jehovah?s name. (Exodus 9:16; Psalm 83:18) How rewarding it is when our evangelizing work helps lovers of truth and righteousness to become praisers of Jehovah! (not witnesses of Christ?) "You young men and also you virgins, you old men together with boys," sang the psalmist. "Let them praise the name of Jehovah, for his name alone is unreachably high. His dignity is above earth and heaven."?Psalm 148:12,13.

    Do you see God?s name or the kingdom mentioned in any of these recommended presentations:

    km 11/01 p. 8 What to Say About the Magazines

    The Watchtower Nov. 15

    "We have heard the expression ?Jesus died for us.? [Quote John 3:16.] Have you ever wondered how the death of one man can save all of us? [Allow for response.] The Bible gives a simple answer. This article, ?Jesus Saves?How?,? clearly explains it."

    Awake! Nov. 22

    "Are humans doing all they can to protect the environment? [Allow for response.] Many wonder if the delicate balance of life on earth will last indefinitely. Thankfully, God is keenly interested. [Read Nehemiah 9:6.] Awake! discusses what the future holds for life on earth."

    The Watchtower Dec. 1

    "This time of year, many people are very involved in gift-giving and other kind deeds. That brings to mind the Golden Rule. [Read Matthew 7:12.] Do you think it is possible to live by that rule all year round? [Allow for response.] This magazine provides much food for thought on ?The Golden Rule?Is It Still Practical??"

    Awake! Dec. 8

    "The Bible promises that one day no one will be able to say, ?I am sick.? [Read Isaiah 33:24.] In line with that promise, this issue of Awake! focuses on an illness that afflicts millions of people, young and old. It is entitled ?Hope for Arthritis Sufferers.? I?m sure you?ll find these articles to be informative."

    Evangelizing Benefits Us Personally

    Paragraph 18

    Doing the work of an evangelizer benefits us personally in various ways. Going from house to house with the good news helps us to cultivate humility, particularly when we are not received in a kind manner.

    To be effective evangelizers, we need to be like Paul, who ?became all things to people of all sorts so that he might save some.? (1 Corinthians 9:19-23) Experience in the ministry helps us to be tactful. By relying on Jehovah and choosing our words well, we can apply Paul?s counsel: "Let your utterance be always with graciousness, seasoned with salt, so as to know how you ought to give an answer to each one."?Colossians 4:6.

    From this paragraph I can tell that many JWs are going out less and less in the ministry. The ones that do are less and less effective. Not going out in the ministry means you are not humble.

    Based on previous admonition from the WTS to elders and congregation book study conductors to take the lead and work with others in the ministry, their humility is slipping.

    Paragraph 19

    The evangelizing work also moves us to rely on God?s holy spirit. (Zechariah 4:6) In turn, its fruitage?"love, joy, peace, long-suffering, kindness, goodness, faith, mildness, self-control"?becomes evident in our ministry. (Galatians 5:22,23) It affects our dealings with people, for yielding to the spirit?s direction helps us to exercise love, to be joyful and peaceable, to be long-suffering and kind, to display goodness and faith, and to manifest mildness and self-control while declaring the good news.

    Did you notice how weird this paragraph is? First the scripture is quoted and then the WTS proceeds to repeat it again. How can the average JW display these qualities in the ministry when they are thinking that 99.9% of them are going to die at Armageddon and are currently living sinfully degrading lives?

    Paragraph 20

    Another blessing that comes to us as evangelizers is that we become more sympathetic.

    When people mention their problems?sickness, unemployment, domestic trials?we do not act as advisers, but we share encouraging and comforting scriptures with them.

    There it is that JWs are not supposed to act as advisers. Yet, they will tell people in and out of the organization not to go to counselors or doctors qualified to handle these problems.

    We are concerned about people who have been blinded spiritually but seem to have a love of righteousness. (2 Corinthians 4:4) And what a blessing it is to render spiritual help to those "rightly disposed for everlasting life"!?Acts 13:48

    Once again, is the concern for people or for themselves? If JWs were not required to report their time to the WTS, how much time would they spend in the door to door work?

    Paragraph 21

    Regular participation in the evangelizing work helps us to keep our mind focused on spiritual things. (Luke 11:34) That surely is beneficial, since we might otherwise yield to materialistic temptations so common in this world.

    Again the old WTS equation

    Drop in hours = materialism

    The apostle John urged Christians: "Do not be loving either the world or the things in the world. If anyone loves the world, the love of the Father is not in him; because everything in the world?the desire of the flesh and the desire of the eyes and the showy display of one?s means of life?does not originate with the Father, but originates with the world. Furthermore, the world is passing away and so is its desire, but he that does the will of God remains forever." (1 John 2:15-17) Keeping busy as evangelizers with plenty to do in the Lord?s work helps us not to love the world.?1 Corinthians 15:58.

    Store Up Heavenly Treasures

    Paragraph 22

    Zealous Kingdom-preaching activity brings lasting benefits.

    Translation: Salvation can be earned through works.

    Jesus showed this when he said: "Stop storing up for yourselves treasures upon the earth, where moth and rust consume, and where thieves break in and steal. Rather, store up for yourselves treasures in heaven, where neither moth nor rust consumes, and where thieves do not break in and steal. For where your treasure is, there your heart will be also."?Matthew 6:19-21.

    I definitely get the message from the WTS that the rank and file are not putting the same amount of time in the ministry as in days gone by. The only reason can be that they are materialistic not that the R&F are getting tired of waiting for the end to come SOON.

    Paragraph 23

    May we keep on storing up treasures in heaven, aware that we could have no greater privilege than that of representing the Sovereign Lord Jehovah as his Witnesses. (Isaiah 43:10-12)

    I thought Christians were supposed to be witnesses of Jesus? The NT only talks about being witnesses of Jesus, not witnesses of Jehovah or even of God.

    Revelation 1:9

    I John, YOUR brother and a sharer with YOU in the tribulation and kingdom and endurance in company with Jesus, came to be in the isle that is called Pat´mos for speaking about God and bearing witness to Jesus.

    Acts 1:8

    but YOU will receive power when the holy spirit arrives upon YOU, and YOU will be witnesses of me both in Jerusalem and in all Ju·de´a and Sa·mar´i·a and to the most distant part of the earth.

    Revelation 17:6

    And I saw that the woman was drunk with the blood of the holy ones and with the blood of the witnesses of Jesus.

    As we carry out our commission as God?s ministers, we may well feel like a Christian woman in her 90?s who said: "Through it all I thank Jehovah for putting up with me all these years (no thanks to Jesus?), and I pray fervently that he will be my loving Father forever." (Where is Jesus in this equation?) If we similarly cherish our relationship with God (not Jesus?) surely we want to do the work of an evangelizer in a complete way. The next article will help us see how we can fully accomplish our ministry.

    Concluding Comments

    This DO MORE article was fairly simple, no "new light." But it does indicate that the rank and file need prodding.

    The only thing I found of note was this in paragraph 2.

    For example, the Congregation Book Study overseer has the rewarding privilege of taking the lead in the preaching work and training others.

    This concept has been around for years but not practiced by any but one conductor years ago. I even mentioned this to several and they looked at me as if I were crazy. When the title was changed from Congregation Book Study conductor to overseer, the idea was that this elder would be working more with those in the book study. I guess the elders are not being obedient. They hardly take the time to work with their wives and children. They are usually too busy working with each other.

    Kingdom Ministry 1/99 p. 8 Overseers Taking the Lead?Congregation Book Study Conductors

    He takes the lead
    in the evangelizing work, knowing that the regularity, zeal, and enthusiasm he shows for the service will be reflected in the rest of the group. (Col. 4:17; 2 Thess. 3:9) In time, he endeavors to work in service with each member of his group. If we want to sharpen our preaching and teaching skills in the ministry, the Congregation Book Study conductor can help us to attain our goal.

    Blondie

    **Supplement: Did Christians go "house to house"?

    Point 1

    http://www.caic.org.au/jws/organization/h-to-h.htm

    Interestingly the 1972 book "Organization for Kingdom Preaching and Disciple Making" (A.K.A. "The Organization Book") comments on the meaning of Acts 20:20. On pages 54-56, it is discussing the role of the body of elders in the congregations of Jehovah's Witnesses. It says the following:
    "However, since the Greek term for 'exercising oversight' (e pi sko pe' o) includes the meaning of 'visiting', it is certainly appropriate that the shepherds visit the brothers in their homes and even in prison, upbuilding them and contributing to their spiritual enlightenment. (Compare Revelation 3:20; Luke 10:38-42; Matthew 25:36,39) Paul reminded the elders of Ephesus that he had taught them, not only publicly, but "from house to house". * (Acts 20:17-20, margin; MO; RS; Lamsa; YG; Dy; Knox; Acts 18:19-21; 19:1-19; 20:31) A congregation was established in Ephesus and other cities. For lack of public meeting places that could be rented or hired, the local congregation would meet in the private home of a dedicated, baptized believer (Rom. 16:5; Col. 4:15; Philem. 2), and to congregational meetings in the homes interested persons could be invited. By these means the members of the congregation would come to know the overseers well and feel free to approach them, and the overseers, in turn, would become better acquainted with the needs of each one of the "flock". It is important for overseers to be approachable, willing to listen when their brothers come to them with problems, and dealing with them in a manner that will result in refreshment as the "fine shepherd" set the example.-Matthew 11:28-30"

    So, the Watchtower Society now applies Acts 20:20 as proving that Paul taught, not unbelievers from house to house, but believers in the homes of believers
    . What scholarly support does the Watchtower Society cite for this interpretation? In a footnote on page 56 of "The Organization Book" it quotes Dr. A. T. Robertson from the book "A Grammer of the Greek New Testament in the Light of Historical Research" (1934). The footnote states:
    "As regards the translation "from house to house" (kat' oi' kous) in Acts 20:20, which some modern translators would render as: "at your houses" (AT), "in your homes" (Je;NE), "in private" (NA), Doctor Robertson has this to say on pages 349,350 paragraph 1: "and from house to house (kai kat'oikous). By (according to) houses. It is worth noting that the greatest of preachers preached form house to house and did not make his visits merely social calls. He was doing kingdom business all the while as in the house of Aquila and Priscilla. (1 Cor. 16:19)"

    1 Corinthians 16:19 says the following:
    "The congregations of Asia send you their greetings. Aquila and Prisca together with the congregation that is in their house greet you heartily in the Lord". (NWT)

    So, evidently this scholar A.T. Robertson, according to the Watchtower Society, interprets Acts 20:20 to be referring to Paul ministering to believers in the congregations that met in the homes of fellow believers and not to unbelievers at their homes.

    Point 2

    http://www.escapefromwatchtower.com/house.html

    Portions of this article have been taken out of the book "In Search of Christian Freedom" by Raymond Franz

    Where did Paul teach and make converts according to All the accounts ?
    • At Pentecost in a Public Place (Acts 2:1-41)
  • In the Synagogue (Acts 13:44-48, 17:1-4)
  • At a River (Acts 16:13)
  • In a Jail (Acts 16:23-40)
  • The Market Place (Acts 17-16-34)
  • There are no accounts of Paul or any other disciples or apostles, making converts by preaching to someone at their front or back door, and going to the next house to preach to another. There are however, accounts of house churches, teaching in private homes. There, persons were invited to "gather together" at one of the small close knit family, house churches that met in private homes. All other accounts of individuals "coming into the truth" are by other means, none of which include a door to door preaching activity, with the statistical recordings of "hours", "return visits", "book & booklet placements" & etc., from an appointed "slave class" of men.

    Point 3

    http://mypage.uniserve.ca/~renford/house.htm

    In my research it appears that the Society uses the two scriptures found in Acts, chapter 5:42 and 20:20 to establish the teaching that we must do house to house work otherwise we are not good Christians.

    The Scripture says " While I [Paul] did not hold back from telling you any of the things that were profitable nor from teaching you publicly and from house to house." It is apparent that they are making the deduction that the house to house means from door to door, in other words going consecutively from one door to the next.

    A couple of things came up when examining the Greek interlinear about this subject for example in Acts 2:46 which says : And day after day they were in constant attendance at the temple with one accord, and they took their meals in private homes and partook of food with great rejoicing and sincerity of heart," then looking at Acts 5:42 it says "And every day in the temple and from house to house they continued without letup teaching and declaring the good news about the Christ, Jesus."

    What I found was that the identical phrase (kat?oikon) translates "from house to house" in the NWT rendered of Acts, chapter 5, verse, also occurs in the chapter two verse 46
    . In examining the Kingdom interlinier you can see the same phrase, with the same distributive sense of kata appears in both texts. Yet in Acts 2:46, the rendering is not from "house to house" but "in private homes"

    Then that same phrase is used again in Acts 20:20 and the NWT renders it again as "house to house"
    In examining other translations of the Bible it is evident that what was meant by this passage was that the instructions given here were not that they were to go from house to house but to go into private homes where they already knew the people and continue to teach them about Christ. What it seems to me is that the Society has tried to convey a meaning that is not actually there.

  • cyber-sista
    cyber-sista

    thanks blondie for all your hard work. It helps to keep up on this stuff as I am still getting hit with it....A sister just wrote me last week and wanted to know if I was getting the magazines and mentioned one of the latest WT studies that you had written a recent post about. It is interesting to know where the JW mindset is heading as I still have some connections with the Org through family, etc.

  • Odrade
    Odrade
    They hardly take the time to work with their wives and children. They are usually too busy working with each other.

    One of my pet peeves back when... I used to say that more sisters would pioneer and for longer if the brothers would actually work in the same cargroup with them. Instead they work with their o'l boy buddies and send the ladies with carloads of kids and a list of not-at-homes. They train them to be in such subjection that they can hardly tie their laces without getting permission or wearing a napkin on their heads, yet the men refuse to take the lead in the cargroups, other than the initial morning bossing of the car orders. bleh. Oh well, it's a good thing for me they don't, means no one calls on me on Saturday mornings. whoohoo!

    thanks for the review.

    Odrade

  • happy man
    happy man
  • happy man
    happy man
  • happy man
    happy man

    Blondie.

    I think you fullfille what Jw say about how we now apostates, we have a speach fore not so long time ago when it was told we rekognise them on that they dont want to go from dor to door to preache.

    You studies is intresting and use to read them very week, but I dont understnad why you complain on going to peopel in ther house to tell them about the kingdom, even if it not was in the bibel I think it is a good ay to find pepoel, dont you?And this is the purpus sint it, to reach so many as possibel widh the good news.

    Something as is vey intresting is why we not are allowed to preach on internet, this is in some way very difficul tto understand, was not the purpus to tell evryone in the world about good news, now we have the tool, but we are not allowed to use it, this dont fitt together.

    I told this on last WT studie, when they say we never can reach out to evryone, I say dont forget internet, we can sitt in our home and talk to peopel from all over the word, it was no comment att all to this, and the condukture was not so happy when i say this WHY?

  • blondie
    blondie

    Cyber-sista,

    A sister just wrote me last week and wanted to know if I was getting the magazines and mentioned one of the latest WT studies that you had written a recent post about. It is interesting to know where the JW mindset is heading as I still have some connections with the Org through family, etc.

    I?m glad the reviews are of some value for you. When you can, please share what you hear is the current JW mindset. It is interesting to see what spin they put on what is in the magazines.

    Odrade,

    I used to say that more sisters would pioneer and for longer if the brothers would actually work in the same cargroup with them. Instead they work with their o'l boy buddies and send the ladies with carloads of kids and a list of not-at-homes.

    That is because they didn?t want the responsibility of taking care of the children. My husband told me that they would do drive-by return visits, cruise by the homes of the inactive and irregular publishers hoping to catch them doing something bad and then go to the coffee shop and drink coffee, eat donuts, and trash the reputation of most of the congregation. He finally took himself out of that loop and started going with the women and kids. Is it surprising that the sisters thought my husband was a wonderful brother and man?

    Happyman, my conscience prodder,

    Actually, statistically, most new JWs are either children/other relatives of JWs, people contacted informally at work or neighbors. 75 percent of the people baptized at the last 10 assemblies/conventions I attended were not contacted in the door to door. Most people are no longer home during the day during the week, few are at home on Saturday. Yet most JWs and congregations do not adjust the times for going out to evenings (before 8 pm) or on Saturday/Sunday evenings when people are likely to be home. So if the WTS wanted to contact the most people?. Many JWs have said they don?t want the responsibility of a bible study; perhaps that is why they do not make effective return visits.

    I told this on last WT studie, when they say we never can reach out to evryone, I say dont forget internet, we can sitt in our home and talk to peopel from all over the word, it was no comment att all to this, and the condukture was not so happy when i say this WHY?

    Let the WTS answer that (the following not endorsed/supported by Blondie):

    km 11/99 p. 3 Use of the Internet?Be Alert to the Dangers! ***

    4

    The Internet enables one to communicate inexpensively with millions of others throughout the world, and it opens the door to vast amounts of information. (Awake!, January 8, 1998) The indiscriminate use of the Internet, however, can expose a person to great spiritual and moral dangers. How is this so?

    5

    Many are concerned about readily available information that shows how to build weapons, including bombs. Industry complains about the amount of time workers waste using the Internet. Much has been stated in our publications about the obvious spiritual dangers encountered on the Internet. Numerous Web sites present violent and pornographic materials that are entirely unsuitable for Christians. (Ps. 119:37) In addition to these dangers, there is a more insidious danger that Jehovah?s Witnesses in particular need to be on guard against. What is this danger?

    6

    Would you invite a stranger into your home without first finding out who he is? What if there was no way to find out? Would you allow such a stranger to be alone with your children? This is an indisputable possibility on the Internet.

    7

    Electronic mail can be sent to and received from people you do not know. The same is true when you converse electronically in a forum or in a chat room. Participants may at times claim to be Jehovah?s Witnesses, but often they are not. Someone may claim to be a youth when he is not. Or a person may even falsely claim to be of a certain gender.

    8

    Information passed on to you may come in the form of experiences or comments about our beliefs. This information is passed on to others who, in turn, pass it on to still others. The information is generally not verifiable and may be untrue. The comments may be a cover for spreading apostate reasoning.?2 Thess. 2:1-3.

    9

    With this danger in mind, if you use the Internet, ask yourself: ?What do I use it for? Is there a possibility that I could be harmed spiritually by how I am using it? Could I be contributing to the spiritual injury of others??

    10

    Web Sites of "Jehovah?s Witnesses": Consider, for example, some Internet sites set up by individuals who claim to be Jehovah?s Witnesses. They invite you to visit their sites to read experiences posted by others who claim to be Witnesses. You are encouraged to share your thoughts and views about the Society?s literature. Some give recommendations about presentations that could be used in the field ministry. These sites offer chat rooms for individuals to connect to, allowing live communication with others, similar to talking on the telephone. They often point you to other sites where you can have on-line association with Jehovah?s Witnesses around the world. But can you tell for certain that these contacts have not been planted by apostates?

    11

    Having association via the Internet may not be consistent with the recommendation found at Ephesians 5:15-17. The apostle Paul wrote: "Keep strict watch that how you walk is not as unwise but as wise persons, buying out the opportune time for yourselves, because the days are wicked. On this account cease becoming unreasonable, but go on perceiving what the will of Jehovah is."

  • jgnat
    jgnat

    I really enjoyed the pointed questions you asked in this study, Blondie. Questions leads to thinking, leads to independent thought.

    My pet peeve from the study this week, is the blatant rewriting of history by the WT for their convenience. Here is a picture of a pair of first-century Jehovah's Witnesses presenting a tract to a householder. What is wrong with this picture?

    http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/file/B857ED86-2CD3-4A34-9C33-0C367BAFE84F.ashx

    Here are some more credible accounts on how the first century church may have operated.

    The House Church: A Missiological Model
    by Del Birkey
    "...the house-church structure was de facto the working model during the first few centuries of the church's missionary advance. "

    House Churches of the past, and how they operate today.

    Corinthian House Churches

    Architecture of Early House Church

    I imagine the story of Jesus dining at the house of Simon gives us a glimpse of how these house visits would have gone. As you have described, Blondie, it was likely a dinner at a fellow Christian's house, with neighbours coming to hear what the speaker had to say. This was a time before the printing press or radio, so a festal gathering like this would be more effective at reaching many people at once with the same message.

    Jesus dining at the house of Simon "Now there was a custom in those days that a visiting rabbi would have delivered a short sermon - setting out his debating stall - so to speak. So Jesus may have preached to the invited guests on the inside and been overheard by others who had gathered outside the wall of the house and who had come to listen."

    More about how Simon?s dinner would have gone "Good manners dictated that Simon give Rabbi Jesus the kiss of peace, wash his feet, and place a drop of attar of roses on his head (or a pinch of incense could be burned). Simon did none of this for Jesus. The scene was in Simon's courtyard. Guests reclined on low couches around a table, on the left elbow, leaving the right hand free. Guests feet were away from the table. Since the public could come in when a rabbi was present, this explains how the woman could be standing at Jesus' feet. (Barclay, DAILY STUDY BIBLE SERIES, LUKE, pp. 92 ff.)"

    Further Reading: The Rise of Christianity: A Sociologist Reconsiders History
    This book is interesting, as it suggests that Christianity dramatically improved the lot of women, and that women were primarily responsible for the vigorous growth of the movement.

    The Salesman as Social Pirate
    Though this article suggests that door-to-door work leads to compassion and humility, I suggest it's primary purpose is to reinforce in the "believer" that they are a persecuted minority. How can "pioneers" possibly gain insight in to the householder's problems, a virtual stranger, in a doorway conversation, where the questions and responses are rehearsed?

    A believer's time would be better spent getting to know their children, relatives, and the people next door by getting together for dinner, and having heart-to-heart talks.

    As the Social Pirate article suggests, cold calls are an assault on the householder's privacy. No wonder they appear hostile. It is not the message they are rejecting, but the presentation!

  • minimus
    minimus

    The scriptures say that not ALL would be evangelizers. "Some" would. Were fishermen, shepherds, herders, mothers, etc. ALL evangelizers? Of course not! Imagine a provider working 15 hours a day at his work coming home to find out his wife and kids were pioneering for the day or even month. Stupid.

  • jgnat
    jgnat

    Good point, Minimus. I am going to remember that one.

  • Share this

    Google+
    Pinterest
    Reddit