What's Your All-Time Fantasy Baseball Team?

by Preston 9 Replies latest social entertainment

  • Preston

    Hmmm...havent seen a Baseball thread on here in a while, anyone have any choices for the perfect All-Time Fantasy Baseball Team (anyone, from any team, at any period of time)?



    C - Josh Gibson

    1st - Jimmie Foxx

    2nd - Rogers Hornsby

    3rd - Brooks Robinson

    Shortstop - Ozzie Smith

    Left P - Lefty Grove

    Right P - Satchel Paige

    Outfield - Willie Mays, Babe Ruth, Ted Williams

  • logansrun

    Good question! Can my response include Sharon Stone anywhere?

  • pr_capone

    Catcher - Josh Gibson
    1st - Lou Gherig
    2nd - Rogers Hornsby
    3rd - Mike Schmidt
    SS - Honus Wagner
    Lefty Starter - Warren Spahn
    Righty Starter - Nolan Ryan
    Relief Pitcher - Dennis Eckersly
    OF - Babe Ruth, Willie Mays, Ty Cobb

    Kansas District Overbeer

  • hillbilly

    Good start Preston....

    I will ponder this and post a list. As good as Josh Gibson was in the Negro era, Johnny Bench may be the best catcher in the modern era yet.


  • ColdRedRain

    Mine, Including DH's, 5 starting pitchers, 2 setup pitchers and 2 closers. IF

    1B: Lou Gherig

    2B: Craig Biggio

    SS: Cal Ripken Jr

    3B: Honus Wagner


    Kirby Pcukett

    Ty Cobb

    Willie Mays

    Pitching rotation:

    Starting Pitchers

    Nolan Ryan

    Sandy Koufax

    Josh Gibson

    Roger Clemens

    John Smoltz

    (The entire starting rotation from the Braves' '90's teams probably.)

    Setup/Middle Reliever: Mariano Rivera

    Closers: Dennis Eckersley

    Sparky Lyle

    DH: Edgar Martinez

    Ruth wouldn't make it on my list because the guy couldn't field worth shit.

  • Preston

    Johnny Bench vs. "The Black Babe Ruth"?


    Bench was great! He was a great defensive player and hit for power during the Reds best years, it would be hard to knock the guy. One can only speculate how Gibson would of played in majors, but still, the guy hit close to 800 homers...

    - Preston

  • Preston
    Ruth wouldn't make it on my list because the guy couldn't field worth shit.

    You included Koufax even though his first five years weren't up to par. Not only was Babe Ruth one of the best hitters of all time, he was also one of the best pitchers when he started for Boston. He's definitely in the rotation...

    - Preston

  • Preston


    Sharon Stone can't play Baseball

    - Preston

  • hillbilly

    While he was not noted for his hitting, Tony Pena, get's high marks from me as a defensive catcher... I think his style has changed the way catchers do the job today.

    Jack Morris has got to be on the short list of pitchers...along with Orel Herscieser (Is the spelling close?)


  • hmike

    1B: Lou Gehrig or Jimmie Foxx

    2B: Rogers Hornsby

    SS: Honus Wagner

    3B: Mike Schmidt or Wade Boggs

    LF: Ty Cobb

    CF: Willie Mays

    RF: Babe Ruth

    C: Mike Piazza

    SP1: Cy Young

    SP2: Walter Johnson

    SP3: Christy Mathewson

    SP4: Grover Alexander

    SP5: Warren Spahn

    RP1: Elroy Face

    RP2: Dennis Eckersly

    Also on the staff: Sandy Koufax, Juan Marichal

    In the dugout: Johnny Bench (C), Pete Rose (1B-2B-3B-OF), Ted Williams (OF), Hank Aaron (OF), Tris Speaker (OF), Cal Ripkin (SS-3B)

Share this