Scientific American: How Do You Distinguish Between Religious Fervor and Mental Illness?

by AndersonsInfo 2 Replies latest jw friends

  • AndersonsInfo

    How Do You Distinguish Between Religious Fervor and Mental Illness?

    It's not meant as insult to believers; the two states of mind can share many similar characteristics

    George Fox, whose visions inspired him to found the Quaker religion in the 1600s, was accused of being a madman. Credit: Part of an engraving by "S. Allen", published in 1838, of a painting by "S. Chinn." The provenance of the original painting is unknown. Wikimedia

    Last year, a news column circulated the web, announcing the American Psychological Association had decided to classify strong religious beliefs as mental illness. According to the article, a five-year study by the APA concluded that devout belief in a deity could hinder “one’s ability to make conscientious decisions about common sense matters.” Refusals by Jehovah’s Witnesses to accept life-saving treatments, such as blood transfusions, were given as an example.

    Of course, this turned out to be a fake news story. But it still drew legitimate media coverage and outrage from readers. Fact-checking websites like Snopes had to point out the column was satirical.

    To many, this was a ridiculous stunt. But for me, a physician specializing in mental health, the satire hits home in many ways. My colleagues and I often care for patients suffering from hallucinations, prophesying, and claiming to speak with God, among other symptoms—in mental health care, it’s sometimes very difficult to tell apart religious belief from mental illness.

    Part of this is because the classification of mental illness often relies on subjective criteria. We can’t diagnose many mental health conditions with brain scans or blood tests. Our conclusions frequently stem from the behaviors we see before us.

    Take an example of a man who walks into an emergency department, mumbling incoherently. He says he’s hearing voices in his head, but insists there’s nothing wrong with him. He hasn’t used any drugs or alcohol. If he were to be evaluated by mental health professionals, there’s a good chance he might be diagnosed with a psychotic disorder like schizophrenia.

    But what if that same man were deeply religious? What if his incomprehensible language was speaking in tongues? If he could hear Jesus speaking to him? He might also insist nothing were wrong with him. After all, he’s practicing his faith.


  • Still Totally ADD
    Still Totally ADD

    Scientific American is one of our favorite maz. we get. Thank you for bringing this point out. Still Totally ADD

  • Vidiot
    "How do you distinguish between religious fervor and mental illness?"

    Meds. :smirk:

Share this