IF it quacks like a duck ...? WHAT IS IT?

by Terry 6 Replies latest jw friends

  • Terry
    Terry
    A QUESTION: "What does IDENTITY mean?"

    If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck have feathers like a duck: IT IS A __?___

    Hans Christian Anderson taught us this lesson in the famous story of
    "THE UGLY DUCKLING"
    (**Spoiler Alert**) the ugly part of the duckling was misleading to observers who later discover it is a SWAN.
    (Cue the music: dun Dun DUNNNNN!)

    Humans aren't exact duplicate copies of their parents.
    The COPY and PASTE contain "mutations".
    A mutant version of a copy may have more disadvantages than advantages. (Sociopath, birth defect, etc.)
    Or?
    Or maybe a chess wizard, math genius, or outstanding inventor, etc.
    It may walk like a Duck, Quack like a Duck, but have feathers like a Swan. (As that story goes...)

    SOCIETY is a large group of humans who instinctively make snap judgments about US and THEM which has been a protective mechanism in the history of families, tribes, and nations.

    Pay attention, Students!
    It all begins with Aristotle who taught:
    "... the IDENTITY of an object is constituted by its properties"
    Translation:
    (A duck walks duck-like, quacks duck-like, is feathered duck-like, etc.)

    Science (Biology) teaches: "An organism has a phenotype and a genotype."
    Translation: "A living thing IS what it looks like and what it does
    (i.e. observable characteristic) PLUS its genotype: (heritable traits.)

    So far what do we know? Are we saying: "IT IS WHAT IT IS?"
    No. That's gibberish.
    Ant colonies post guards which sniff all who enter for chemical signals which either allow entrance or alert "DANGER"!
    This knee-jerk protective instinct works great until it doesn't.
    One ant species sends out a trickster who shows up and fails the sniff test and gets carried off and tossed out as a bouncer does with a drunk.
    (The trickster keeps coming back! Again and again, until it has rubbed off the molecules of SCENT onto itself and smells like the guards!
    UH OH!
    The trickster-ant passes the sniff test, infiltrates the colony, and gets the layout for "nefarious purposes." (Assassinate the queen and kidnap the pupae to raise as the next generation of slaves.)


    ANTS TAKE SLAVES! The mind boggles!

    ______
    Human immune system defense is fantastic at determining
    one thing very quickly: "LIKE ME? or NOT LIKE ME".

    A foreign substance entering our body has to pass this sorting sentinel's "LIKE ME or NOT LIKE ME" to avoid being attacked and destroyed.
    NATURE consists of organisms that can sort correctly or perish.

    (Seamless transition alert!)

    POLITICS is part of the sorting mechanism.
    Politicians are like Trickster Ants.
    The would-be elected official bumps into opposition again and again until it smells like "one of us."
    If Voters agree a candidate "smells okay", that critter infiltrates our social immune system and begins tampering with everything.

    A virus too! It tricks our immune system and carries us off as its slave!

    A social movement too! A religion can infiltrate our thinking and carry us off as its slave! __________

    WE LIVE IN A TIME where sorting is NOT being made easy.
    Definitions are changing of what a DUCK IS or IS NOT.

    "Trickster-ants" are everywhere claiming to be just like us and they are not.
    Rules are tampered with, policies are re-jiggered little by little unit every member of our species is DEMANDING to infiltrate no matter what they smell like.

    WE HAVE LOST our connection with Nature.
    We cannot rely on "instincts" any longer for defense.

    We are forbidden to sort ducks.
    OUR SPECIES no longer IS what it IS.

    Good or Bad, right or wrong, this is our landscape.
    Adapt or perish is the way into the future.

    You don't have to like it - do you?
    In fact, how you FEEL about it is your problem.

    BE who you are or be who others say you are: that is the choice.
    Fit in, sneak in, barge in, break-in, vote in; impeach out, toss out, vote out, shout out --- it is UP TO YOU.

    CHOICE and RIGHTS are now "snowclones." (Definition: "a multi-use, customizable, instantly recognizable, time-worn, quoted or misquoted phrase or sentence that can be used in an entirely open array of different variants" )

    Our IDENTITY has been taken captive and we are hollowed out as slaves to ideology.
    ________
    We are the hollow men
    We whisper together
    Are quiet and meaningless
    As wind in dry grass
    Or rats' feet over broken glass
    In our dry cellar
    The eyes are not here
    There are no eyes here
    In this valley of dying stars
    In this hollow valley
    Between the idea
    And the reality
    Between the motion
    And the act
    Falls the Shadow
    Between the conception
    And the creation
    Between the emotion
    And the response
    Falls the Shadow
    Between the desire
    And the spasm
    Between the potency
    And the existence
    Between the essence
    And the descent
    Falls the Shadow
    This is the way the world ends
    This is the way the world ends
    This is the way the world ends
    Not with a bang but a whimper.
    _________
    T.S. Eliot (The Hollow Men)


  • Simon
    Simon

    If it quacks like a duck then it isn't a duck, it's a duck-call.

    If it quacks as a duck then it is in fact a duck.

  • LoveUniHateExams
    LoveUniHateExams

    Science (Biology) teaches: "An organism has a phenotype and a genotype." - yes, this is correct, established science.

    All the following are human phenotypes, coded for by genotypes:

    eye colour

    skin colour

    height

    weight

    body fat

    muscle mass

    male/female (biological sex, not 'gender')

    behaviour

  • Terry
    Terry

    I remember my earliest conversations with my best friend (who just happened to be a Jehovah's Witness, whatever the hell that was ...).
    Johnny kept saying things that "bumped into" my understanding of how things are.
    These weren't arguments. Not at first.
    These were challenges.
    I could either ignore these dissonances or question them, you see...

    Challenges (bumps) continued.
    The idea was to erode my view of reality. (I don't mean Johnny saw it this way. It is what JW's are trained to do and it's the "life-saving" work of any evangelist :)

    Pretty soon his persuasions wore off my edges and I started to smell like his ideas.
    IRONICALLY, JW's have reverse engineered the Ant Trickster strategy.
    THEY RUB OFF ON YOU and get you to infiltrate the Kingdom Hall where
    THEY CARRY YOU OFF as their mental slave.

    Ontologically, words and their meanings are CHANGED (tampered).
    Different use of words leads to a different understanding of "meaning" itself.

    A VIRUS hijacks and takes over and so does religion and so does a political ideology.

    GENDER issues and POLITICAL CORRECTNESS too.
    CENSORSHIP and WOKENESS too.

    The world I grew up in no longer exists untampered, un "bumped".





  • MeanMrMustard
    MeanMrMustard
    IF it quacks like a duck ...? WHAT IS IT?

    A witch.

  • mikronboy
    mikronboy

    Could be a platypus.

  • Terry
    Terry

    The twentieth century has been characterized by three developments of great political importance: the growth of democracy, the growth of corporate power, and the growth of corporate propaganda as a means of protecting corporate power against democracy.

    Magazine ADs in the early years of my life used a kind of reverse "guilt by association"
    with a half-naked model standing next to an automobile, a sports hero eating a box of Wheaties, or a rich celebrity wearing some trendy item of fashion thus implying that
    the Product = the user's beauty, cash, success.

    Removing criticism, silencing nay-sayers, threatening dissidents was very much a part of being a JW and now in Society at large by politics, media, and corporate technocrats.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit