QFR Confess to Elders?WT June 1,2001
Article in full....................
Questions From Readers
In view of Jehovah’s willingness to forgive sins by the merit of the ransom sacrifice, why is it necessary for Christians to confess to the older men in the congregation?
As can be seen in the case of David and Bath-sheba, Jehovah forgave David’s sin, grave though it was, because of David’s genuine repentance. When the prophet Nathan approached him, David openly confessed: “I have sinned against Jehovah.”—2 Samuel 12:13.
However, Jehovah not only accepts a sinner’s sincere confession and extends forgiveness but he also makes loving provisions to help the erring one progress to spiritual recovery. In David’s case, the help came through the prophet Nathan. Today, in the Christian congregation, there are spiritually mature older men, or elders. The disciple James explains: “Is there anyone [spiritually] sick among you? Let him call the older men of the congregation to him, and let them pray over him, greasing him with oil in the name of Jehovah. And the prayer of faith will make the indisposed one well, and Jehovah will raise him up. Also, if he has committed sins, it will be forgiven him.”—James 5:14, 15.
Skillful elders can do much to ease the pain of heart that is felt by the remorseful sinner. They strive to imitate Jehovah in their
dealings with him. They never want to be harsh, even though strong discipline maybe warranted. Rather, they compassionately consider the immediate needs of the individual. Patiently they strive to readjust erring one’s thinking by using God’s Word. (Galatians 6:1) Even if a person does not voluntarily confess his sin, he may still be moved repentance when approached by the elders, as David was when approached by Nathan. The support thus rendered by the elders helps the one to avoid the danger of repeating the sin and the serious consequences of becoming a hardened practicer of sin.—Hebrews 10:26-31.
It is certainly not easy to confess to others deeds that one feels ashamed of and to seek forgiveness. It takes inner strength. Reflect for a moment, though, on the alternative. One man who failed to reveal his serious sin to the elders in the congregation said: “l felt a pain in my heart that would not go away. I increased my efforts in the preaching work, but the sickening feeling remained.” He felt that confession to God in prayer was enough, but clearly it was not, for he experienced feelings similar to King David’s. (Psalm 51:8, 11) How much better to accept the loving assistance that Jehovah provides through the elders!
THE WATCHTOWER • JUNE 1, 2001 31
end of article.................
The bible does mention confessing sins but in the context of confessing directly without the elder ‘filter’ and of course those so doing are grateful to Jesus/God and not the elders!
*** Rbi8 1 John 1:9 - 2:2 ***
If we confess our sins, he is faithful and righteous so as to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all unrighteousness. 10 If we make the statement: “We have not sinned,” we are making him a liar, and his word is not in us.
2 My little children, I am writing YOU these things that YOU may not commit a sin. And yet, if anyone does commit a sin, we have a helper with the Father, Jesus Christ, a righteous one. 2 And he is a propitiatory sacrifice for our sins, yet not for ours only but also for the whole world’s.
Why go beyond that? Especially since the account of David and Nathan was pre-Christ and you really doubt that many elders will consider anyone that did not confess voluntarily as ‘repentant’.Although how many judicial committees would have considered David repentant?
In the TMS program, there's this bit about the Catholic Church tradition of confessing sins to a Priest being unscriptural. So, the JW practice of confessing sins to elders is scriptural because the elders are not Priests? Fuzzy logic. And I even wish it was as useful as fuzzy logic.
David and Nathan: David did not report himself. God sent Nathan to him. So, there's no basis for comparing David's case with what is being argued here. David confessed to Jehovah, although in Nathan's presence. In James 5:14,15, the word 'spiritually' is conveniently inserted. Why add to the bible? In fact, the "Also" in the concluding sentence strongly suggests that the preceeding sentence was not about spiritual sickness (recall: greasing wit oil in God's name...) And, do elders always pray with a 'sinner' who confesses? No! they don't!
"It is certainly not easy to confess to others deeds that one feels ashamed of and to seek forgiveness..." Clever! Note the use of "others". Not just anyone, but the elders, who are qualified as being 'skillful'. So if an elder handles a case and performs badly he's not just a skillful elder...
In the saying of many words there does not fail to be transgression...
When I was 19 and had sin in my life I felt moved to confess to the body of elders. When I did it I was disfellowshipped for being unrepentant of the sin. Ha! Why would I even GO to them if I was unrepentant??? I did feel bad about what I had done and STILL got the boot. That's Christian love for you!
Fuzzy logic indeed!