In the Australian Royal Commission, the issue of appointment of ministerial servants and elders came up for intense scrutiny.
Using the elders books and society publication references, the prosecution questioned the premise that "Holy Spirit directs appointments"
The question was proposed as to whether this "process was accurate or was it flawed" seeing as many appointed ones were in fact not very righteous, or "spiritual"
Indeed, the issue about "spirituality" was also raised, and the definition of what makes someone "spiritually mature" in the organisation's eyes was raised. Was it "based on outward appearances and activity within the congregation?...."
The dignified, well presented and poised manner of the commission's questioning is something to behold.