DEITY OF THE HOLY SPIRIT -
JEHOVAH'S WITNESSES DON'T SEE THE HOLY SPIRIT AS GOD. Instead they claim that The Holy Spirit is merely an impersonal "force" or "power")
FOR THOSE WHO MAY BE INTERESTED, HERE ARE SOME OF THEIR OBJECTIONS TO THE PERSONHOOD OF THE HOLY SPIRIT AND HOW THEY MIGHT BE ANSWERED.
I: OBJECTIONS:
OBJECTION 1: The Holy Spirit is called the "power of God" Ro.15:13,19
How can "a power" be a person?
SOLUTION 1: I Cor. 1:24 Jesus is also called "the power of God".
Does that mean that Jesus is not a person?
NOTE: Persons in scripture are often identified
by pertinent impersonal characteristics such as
"power, light, wisdom, love etc."
OBJECTION 2: The Holy Spirit is said to "fill" (play ru o) people.
How can a person be filled by another person?
SOLUTION 2: Eph.1:23 Christ is said to "fill all things"
Acts 5:3-4 Satan "fills" (play ru o) Ananias' heart.
Does that mean Satan is not a person?
fill = play ru o meaning to furnish or influence
(i.e. to be completely influenced by)
OBJECTION 3: John baptized with water, Jesus with the Spirit (Mt.3:11)
Water is not a person, how can the Spirit be a person?
SOLUTION 3: Ro.6:3 Those baptized into Christ, baptised into death.
Does the fact that death is not a person mean that Jesus
is not a person? See also Gal.3:27 (FAULTY LOGIC)
OBJECTION 4: Acts 2:33; 10:45 says the Spirit is "poured out"
How can a person be "poured out"?
SOLUTION 4: Phil 2:17 Paul says "I have been poured out" See also II Tim 4:6
II: QUESTIONS FOR JWs TO CONSIDER:
1. IF THE HOLY SPIRIT IS NOT GOD, WHY IS THE HOLY SPIRIT IDENTIFIED AS GOD IN SCRIPTURE?
- Isn't the Holy Spirit identified as God in Acts 5:3-4?
- Can an impersonal forced be sinned against and
lied to? (verse 3) (also Mk.3:29)
- Isn't the Holy Spirit called Jehovah God?(II Cor.3:17?NWT)
2. COULD A NON PERSONAL UNTHINKING, UNFEELING FORCE BE IDENTIFIED AS OUR "TEACHER" AND OUR "COMFORTER"?
- These personal, care giving roles of the Holy Spirit don't
suggest personality to you?
- Can a non personal force be insulted? (Heb 10:29)
3. ISN'T THE PERSON HOOD OF THE HOLY SPIRIT ESTABLISHED BY HIS ACTIONS IN SCRIPTURE?
- Can a non personal, unthinking, unfeeling force speak
(Acts 10:19) and call men to service? (Acts 13:2)
- Can a non personal force intercede for people? (Ro.8:26)
- How do you know the devil (the unholy spirit) is a person?
4. WHAT ARE THE ESSENTIAL ELEMENTS OF PERSONALITY?
- Aren't all three aspects of personality ascribed to the Holy Spirit?
- INTELLECT (Ro.8:27)
- EMOTIONS (Eph.4:30)
- WILL (I Cor.12:11)
5. IS IT POSSIBLE TO KNOW AND HAVE FELLOWSHIP WITH A FORCE OR POWER?
- Can you explain John 14:17 and II Cor.13:13?