Witnesses play down transfusions for premature sextuplets

by freefly 7 Replies latest watchtower beliefs

  • freefly
    freefly

    http://www.canada.com/vancouversun/news/story.html?id=fcbed172-f4b3-4d3e-8dc0-1fa34a2c959c&k=1815

    (BC Canada)

    VANCOUVER - The Jehovah's Witnesses national organization issued a statement Wednesday in an attempt to quell widespread media speculation about the medical treatment of sextuplets born prematurely to a woman at B.C. Women's Hospital.spokesman Mark Ruge said the statement was issued as a response to the stories, and that it's premature to speculate about the need for medical and legal intervention...

    The Jehovah's Witnesses statement was released after front-page stories in national and Vancouver newspapers Wednesday indicating the issue of the babies' treatment may end up in court because of the blood-transfusion ban.....

    _________________________

    Hi!

    I am writing a letter to our Vancouver Sun newspaper in response to this statement:

    ''It is important for the media and others to avoid making stereotypical assumptions regarding Jehovah's Witnesses,'' the statement said....

    "avoid making stereotypical assumptions"

    freefly

  • purplesofa
    purplesofa

    what is.......minimizing blood sampling......used in the article?

    Thanks for posting

    purps

  • purplesofa
    purplesofa

    Witnesses play down transfusions for premature sextuplets

    Randy Shore, with files from Pamela Fayerman, CanWest News Service; Vancouver Sun

    Published: Thursday, January 11, 2007

    VANCOUVER - The Jehovah's Witnesses national organization issued a statement Wednesday in an attempt to quell widespread media speculation about the medical treatment of sextuplets born prematurely to a woman at B.C. Women's Hospital.

    ''Discussions about treatment are private matters between the parents and their treating medical team,'' it reads.

    The brief text states that church members are allowed to receive any modern medical intervention, except blood transfusions. Several alternative treatments have been employed successfully in the treatment of premature infants, it says, including minimizing blood sampling, and using the hormone erythropoietin and iron to stimulate production of red blood cells.

    Neonatologists say blood transfusions are routine for infants of 25-week gestational age. Transfusions are used to treat anemia and jaundice and may also be needed because premature babies have very low blood volume and hospital staff need to draw blood regularly to monitor the infants' health.

    The Jehovah's Witnesses statement was released after front-page stories in national and Vancouver newspapers Wednesday indicating the issue of the babies' treatment may end up in court because of the blood-transfusion ban.

    Church spokesman Mark Ruge said the statement was issued as a response to the stories, and that it's premature to speculate about the need for medical and legal intervention.

    ''It is important for the media and others to avoid making stereotypical assumptions regarding Jehovah's Witnesses,'' the statement said.

    It also quotes from a 2004 ruling by the Alberta Court of Queen's Bench that it says directs governments and the courts to avoid the assumption that ''the doctor has always recommended the only acceptable treatment'' and that patients are ''always wrong'' to refuse transfusions.

    Matt Gordon, spokesman for the Ministry of Children and Family Development, would not say whether the ministry has had any contact with staff or administrators at B.C. Women's Hospital about the sextuplets. But he said that if health care workers believe a child's health is at risk because a parent has refused to consent to treatment recommended by a doctor, they have a legal duty tell a child protection worker.

    At that point, he said, the ministry would take steps to ensure a child's safety, which might include seeking a court order to allow treatment or, in cases where quick action is needed to preserve life or prevent permanent harm, taking immediate temporary custody of the child.

    The B.C. government has previously used the courts to attempt to force minors to undergo potentially life-saving procedures.

    A Jehovah's Witness teenager was ordered by the B.C. Supreme Court to undergo blood transfusions as part of her cancer treatment in 2005. The court said that because the girl, then 14, was a minor, she could not refuse transfusions if doctors deemed them medically necessary.

    She fled to Ontario and eventually received bloodless treatment in New York after the B.C. government negotiated a deal with her family for her transfer to Schneider Children's Hospital, which specializes in ''blood avoidance'' treatment.

    [email protected]

    Vancouver Sun

  • robhic
    robhic
    what is.......minimizing blood sampling......used in the article?

    Perhaps someone more knowledgeable will post, but, to me, I am guessing that reducing blood samples taken from babies that are so young and small would be fairly important. Any samples would have an impact as blood-loss in ones so tiny.

  • freefly
    freefly

    this article may explain better:

    http://www.canada.com/edmontonjournal/news/story.html?id=b0fc9fd4-35b8-4044-8c97-35efdd6136dc&k=81087

    VANCOUVER - The British Columbia government says it's ready to step in to protect the health rights of premature sextuplets born in Vancouver.

    While the parents of the six babies have remained anonymous in the midst of increasing public scrutiny, they have acknowledged they are Jehovah's Witnesses. The sect's well-known belief that God forbids blood transfusions could lead to a courtroom clash over medical and religious rights.

    The babies, born at 25 weeks gestation, are about the size of a hand and weigh only 700 to 800 grams.

    It is common for premature babies to require blood transfusions due to the number of tests they undergo leading to blood loss.

    An official with the Ministry of Children and Family Development, speaking generally, said the government is prepared to take temporary custody of any children whose lives are at risk.

    He would not comment on whether the government has contacted the parents.

    All health-care workers have a legal duty to report to the ministry cases where parents have refused a doctor's recommended treatment that puts a child's life at risk.

    ''We would then assess and ensure appropriate steps have been taken to ensure the child's safety. In other words, we'd confer with medical experts involved and in cases where they deem treatment is necessary to preserve a child's life, then it'd be necessary for us to seek a court order - and that's what we'd do,'' said the official.

    Such a court order was sought in 2005 for a Jehovah's Witness teenager, who was ordered by the B.C. Supreme Court to undergo blood transfusion as part of her cancer treatment.

    She later received bloodless treatment in New York after negotiating with the B.C. government.

    The national spokesman for Jehovah's Witnesses in Canada would not comment on what the church would do if the government intervened.

    Mark Ruge, church spokesman, says the choice of treatment remains a private matter between the parents and the medical team.

    ''It is important for the media and others to avoid making stereotypical assumptions regarding Jehovah's Witnesses,'' said Ruge.

    He emphasized doctors have treated premature babies without blood transfusions by ''careful attention to minimal blood sampling, clinical acceptance of lower hemoglobin levels, use of erythropoietin and iron to stimulate natural production of red blood cells and other recognized medical procedures.''

    But clarifications over the years have only made things more confusing for many followers.

    In 2000, the official Watchtower church magazine stated due to ambiguity in the Bible, followers may now take certain components of blood for medical treatment.

    While the ban on blood transfusion remains, the new directive opened the door for use of such compounds as hemoglobin, obtained from fractioning red blood cells.

    But a schism within the tightly disciplined sect has led some followers to go as far as campaigning for a stop to the blood ban.

    The Associated Jehovah's Witnesses for Reform on Blood, founded in 1997 by dissenting elders, promotes reform of the ''irrational aspects'' of the blood policy.

    The group protects its members' identities, and asks those looking to join its e-mail list to avoid using their real names.

    Its website lists Jehovah's Witnesses who have died for refusing blood transfusions.

    [email protected]

    Vancouver Province

  • A Paduan
    A Paduan

    The critical care of some patient groups require frequent blood sampling for titration of therapy - hourly is not uncommon. Even with the use of dedicated lines there is a small amount of waste incurred. It can add up, and as stated above, particularly for a small individual - whose total blood volume (if well) may be something like 1/3 of a cup. At even 1 millilitre per sample, one day's worth is a quarter of the patient's blood.

  • orbison11
    orbison11

    saw on our local tv, vancouver, last night that it is costing $12,000 per day for the children, and will cost $1 million by the time they come to term

    they (the parents) must be in such a state, i feel for them

    wendy

  • A Paduan
    A Paduan

    Just and addit

    One doesn't need to be a jw in any way, shape or form to realise that minimising sampling quantities is important. The wt would have people believe that the medical fraternity are mad blood careless infectors, rather than highly learned and detailed physicians.

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit