# If A > B, and B > C, then A > C

by JH 8 Replies latest jw friends

• ##### JH

If A is greater than B, and B is greater than C, then A is greater than C

So, if God can't lie

And the Watchtower has a history of bad predictions and flip flops,

Then

The Watchtower was never inspired by God

• ##### Billzfan23

Here's one that's just as good. If the scriptures set the qualifications for appointment, and "holy spirit" appoints brothers through the governing body, then the "holy spirit" can't tell whether the brothers are qualified or not because over and over again - we find that appointed brothers live double lives and are complete fakes. So the governing body has no "holy spirit". How do ya like me now?

• ##### geevee

Hi Guys,
Done the math, both equations are right, you both go to the top of the class, and your reasoning is that simple, why didn't I see it 20 years ago?

• ##### sspo

If FDS openly confesses they are not inspired of God and have direct communication with Him then why do they force people to view the FDS as if what they say, is from God and DF anyone that does not agree with them.

• ##### Finally-Free

If (Men of Sodom will be resurrected) = truth AND (Men of Sodom will NOT be resurrected) = truth

then (Men of Sodom will be resurrected) = (Men of Sodom will NOT be resurrected)

W

• ##### PrimateDave

God said: Eat the fruit and you will die that very day.
The Snake said: You won't die. You will know Good and Bad.
Adam and Eve got to know Good and Bad, and they didn't die that day.
Who is the liar?

Dave

• ##### becca1

If we are to understand "abstain" from blood as including all methods of taking in blood, then accepting fractions breaks the command to "abstain" from blood. Either the interpretation of "abstain" is too broad or taking fractions is against God's requirements. You can't have both. Logic 101.

• ##### Justice-One

This is the way most JW's view things....A > B so B > A. Think about it, you see it all the time with them.

• ##### Undecided

God doesn't speak english so A B or C has nothing to do with him.

Ken P.