How Is Compulsion of Martyrdom Ethical?

by metatron 3 Replies latest jw friends

  • metatron
    metatron

    I had a somewhat heated conversation with a Circuit Overseer , recently. He became vehement

    in asserting that the organization had an absolute right to expel people for accepting blood transfusions.

    No matter how they spin it, that is their present standard, no matter what deceptive language they use to cover it up.

    In addition, they maintain local crews of elders in "Visitation Committees" who can monitor compliance in hospitals.

    But one question remains:

    How can anyone say that enforced martydom is moral?

    Suppose Jesus drags himself to execution - after being threatened with losing his family? Would that be right?

    Would it be OK with the Society if Witness children face a beating or other punishment if they don't peddle magazines

    from door to door? Suppose elders are forbidden to resign, or face being disfellowshipped? How about forcing your

    kid to get baptized by withholding their allowance or automotive privileges? Is that OK?

    Christianity is founded upon martyrdom and willing self sacrifice, as a matter of history. How then does

    the Watchtower maintain its blood transfusion standard by deliberate compulsion and quiet threats

    - especially when such are made in the context of being sick, vunerable, and often dependent on one's

    family?

    metatron

  • Scully
    Scully

    I suppose for a Jehovah's Witness, you're basically damned if you do, and damned if you don't.

    If you do not VoluntarilyTM martyr yourself by abstaining from blood transfusions, it automatically becomes a VoluntaryTM social martyrdom of sorts.

    I agree with the highly unethical "double bind" situation that such a person would be in. Kind of like having Jim Jones holding a gun to your head and telling you that if you don't drink the Kool-Aid, he's going to send you to meet your Maker anyway.

    By the way, I am becoming more and more perturbed by the reports that I'm hearing of JWs entering the hospital under the guise of "Pastoral Care Visitation" using this as a means of gaining access to confidential patient information. I would really like to develop a professional brochure / letter that might help to circumvent unethical access to patient charts, particularly when JWs could use that information as a means of initiating Judicial Committee proceedings against a JW patient.

  • No Apologies
    No Apologies

    Scully,

    By the way, I am becoming more and more perturbed by the reports that I'm hearing of JWs entering the hospital under the guise of "Pastoral Care Visitation" using this as a means of gaining access to confidential patient information.

    It does not suprise me in the least that they would attempt things like this. What I would find amazing is if their attempts were successful. Aren't hospitals much more strict about who can look at patient information these days? What with HIPPA and all that?

    And what happened to your avatar? Please tell me you did not get a tat?

    No Apologies

  • badboy
    badboy

    CAN ANYONE DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS?

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit