Judicials Committees " fearful power "!!!

by MacHislopp 4 Replies latest jw friends

  • MacHislopp
    MacHislopp

    Hello everyone,

    Please , before you continue the reading …relax…you'll need!

    Let's travel back in time, to the year 1958, and imagine to be among

    the 148,046 audiences , on Wednesday , August 2 nd and the place:

    Yankee Stadium-PoloGrounds, New York City, for the "Divine Will"

    International Assembly of Jehovah's Witnesses.

    The evening speaker is F.W. Franz, vicepresident of the Watch Tower

    Society, the them of his discourse " Keeping Strict Watch on How We Walk".

    (Eph. 5:15)

    "…Pointing up the need of constant prayerful vigilance, Franz told his hearers

    that for each of the five years from March, 1952, to April, 1957, there had been

    an average of 500 persons disfellowshiped from congregations in the United States.

    "However," he said, " during the past year , from April 1957, to April, 1958, the

    numbers rose sharply above that yearly average to 1,334 delinquent members, or more than two and a half times as many." The Society's vice-president further stated: " We dare not dull the shock of this by arguing that this may , in part , be due to American congregations having at least 18,537 new persons associating

    themselves with the witnessing activities this past year." He proved statistically

    that " this definitely disclose that more than twice as many as in previous years

    have failed to watch themselves and act wisely.

    It was made apparent that if anyone commits a sin deserving disfellowshiping

    he should be painfully grieved, should repent and confess his sin, not just to God,

    but to God's visible organization through his local theocratically appointed servants. The Society's vice-president instructed overseers who receive reports

    of some delinquent member of the congregation to investigate the matter and take steps concerning it.

    Regarding disfellowshiping, he said: " The primary righteous purpose of this is to keep God's visible organization of his sheep clean and safe from a spread of sinfulness. The recovery of the offender is secondary." At a hearing before the congregation committee, it was pointed out , the offender or supposed offender, should not attempt to justify himself but ought to seek the unity of the theocratic

    organization and should be concerned with settling matters quickly. Only then "

    is he in a right condition to offer sacrifice to God and to find acceptance with him."

    Noting that congregation service committees have what he termed " fearful power" to disfellowship unruly ones, Franz admonished : " They must use this power with caution, not only to avoid getting into legal difficulties with the law courts of the land, but also to avoid sinning with this disfellowshiping power

    through a misuse or an abuse of it."

    In conclusion the Society's vice-president told his listeners that wisdom and salvation lie in ' keeping a strict watch on how we walk'. «

    (The 1958 REPORT - "Divine Will" International Assembly of Jehovah's Witnesses, Yankee Stadium-Polo Grounds, New York City, Agust, 2, 1958 .pp.54,55 )

    I 've found these revealing points:

    1)"…above that yearly average to 1,334 delinquent members,.."

    2) "…He proved statistically.."

    3) " he should be painfully grieved.."

    4)" …should repent and confess his sin.."

    5)" .. not just to God, but to God's visible organization through

    his local theocratically appointed servants."

    6) "…instructed overseers who receive reports of some

    delinquent member.."

    7)"…keep God's visible organization of his sheepclean

    and safe from a spread of sinfulness. "

    8)" …The recovery of the offender is secondary."

    9)"… seek the unity of the theocratic organization .."

    10)"… should be concerned with settling matters quickly."

    11) ".. At a hearing before the congregation committee.."

    12) " that congregation service committees have what

    he termed " fearful power" !!!

    13) " They must use this power with caution,

    not only to avoid getting into legal

    difficulties with the law courts of the land.."

    I'm sure that this could be useful even if only as a thought provoking material. I do have the original - 112 pages ' brochure.’ -.

    Greetings, James Charles MacHislopp

  • minimus
    minimus

    I'd like to see those that have been disfellowshipped take legal action against the Society for a legally valid reason. If the Society has worried about this matter, there must be a good reason for it. After reading the testimonials of people regarding not having fair hearings or even being invited to a hearing, I would think that SOMETHING could be done about the unfairness that has gone on for decades.

  • Gopher
    Gopher

    There were only 500 American JW's disfellowshipped per year during the mid-50's? It sounds like JW-land was a lot less of a "controlling" place to be back then!!

    But then FW Franz gets out the whip:

    "At a hearing before the congregation committee, it was pointed out , the offender or supposed offender, should not attempt to justify himself but ought to seek the unity of the theocratic organization and should be concerned with settling matters quickly. Only then is he in a right condition to offer sacrifice to God and to find acceptance with him."

    Oh wonderful! Isn't a person innocent until proven guilty? Oh yeah, this is JW-land, not a free society. Anyhow, what if the "supposed offender" has a good point? What if he is merely in disagreement over a doctrine, and later the WTS takes the exact stand the "supposed offender" did? What if (as in many cases) the "offender" is on the elder's "bad side", is not in the right "group of friends" in the congregation, and is thus more easily disposed of?

    Why should an individual who feels he is in the right "not attempt to justify himself but seek unity"? What has he done wrong? It sounds like "confess and we'll let you belong to our group".

    I came across "fearful power" and felt I had no chance when faced with a committee meeting in 2000. So I just sat there and took it, and didn't appeal the decision (what good would that have done??). In retrospect, I'm glad they used their "fearful power" against me ... it opened my eyes as to the unloving nature of the entire WTS organization (and I don't mean all individual JW's, but the supposedly "perfect" organization). My disfellowshipping was the best thing that could have happened. I am now free.

  • Francois
    Francois

    Remember that in the 50s, there were only about 600,000 JWs in the US, if that many. So relatively speaking where would that put the number df'ed in comparison to today?

    francois

  • Gopher
    Gopher

    Francois,

    In recent decades, the disfellowshipping rate worldwide has been about 1% of the number of publishers.

    So if there were 600,000 JW's in America in a given year, then about 6,000 would have been disfellowshipped at that rate (rather than the 1,000 disfellowshipped figure for the 1957-58 year cited earlier).

Share this

Google+
Pinterest
Reddit