MemberPostViewed: times
AlexiaNot sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"


LONG story short: Forgive my grammar, I’m in a hurry!

I grew up as a JW by my mother who was baptized about two years before I was born. My dad studied but was a severe (really severe) alcoholic and my older brother studied but was never really into it.


She did not divorce him despite the alcoholism, verbal abuse, driving us children around while stone drunk and having minor accidents with us in the car (SOMONE was looking after us). The elders told her that that she had to remain with him. Years later when I was 16, he started using crack and steeling from the home and stole thousands of dollars out of my mom’s checking account one time. The brothers in this new congregation we started attending told her she can divorce and still be free to marry if she wanted (which after 27 years of Hell, she didn’t!).

I was sexually assaulted when I was 9-12 many times by some boys the went to a middle school. One of then just was the son of an elder. I told my mother and we went to the brothers and they pretty much blew me off because I didn’t “scream” like some account in the Bible were Taymor? Taimor? did or didn’t scream when was raped by her brother. I was scared to death during those years. I couldn’t run, let alone scream. My case was essentially dismissed by them. That has left a horrible scar on me.


I got baptized when I was 17. I didn’t know what I wanted out of life though. I had already started to slip away a couple years back, had boyfriends and sex, experimented with weed and alcohol (just occasionally), but still attended all meetings and FS because my mother was my influence. I pretty much got baptized for my mother.

By 19-20, I really wanted to get married. Mostly because I wanted to stop committing fornication! At 20 I married a ministerial servant who I later found out didn’t want to work, wanted me to support him, owned guns (secretly but legally). I found out later that he had this horrible dark side that wanted to murder women. I know this sound odd but I was practically married to a potential serial killer. He said Jehovah was the only thing keeping him from acting out.

I stayed with him for three years. I supported him financially and emotionally. Then he started to physically abuse me. I woke up one night with his hands around my neck for no reason. We also had an argument where he attacked me in the same way. Stupidly, I didn’t leave him until 6 months later. When I told the elders why, they pretty much blew me off and asked why I didn’t tell them sooner. They didn’t believe me because I waited almost six months to report him. They didn’t ask me if I went to the police, filed a report or anything. I was told if I divorce, I wouldn’t be free to remarry. They never questioned him about his actions. That was the end of that discussion. This was summer of 2002.

I left him, filed divorce, got my own place and never went to another meeting except the Memorial which I stopped going last year.

I’m in another relationship with a sane man and we have the upmost respect for each other. I had other relationships and flings but there were not long-term. This is.

So here is the problem:

My mother, who is still very active in the congregation, knows nothing about this. “This” meaning my not attending meetings, not going to the memorials, I have no publications; she doesn’t know I have relationships, sex, nothing.

I don’t want disassociate myself because I love my mother (despite her past faults) and it would crush her to know end. We are not very close but we talk about 2-3 a month by phone. Whenever she brings up the society, I pretend I know what she’s talking about. I get most of my information about what’s going on like the Watchtower changes and the new “Bible Study” arrangement from sites such as this one.

Any advice? I know this is a hard one, but any experiences or words would help. If it wasnt for her, I would have DF myself long ago.
IP: nWGyLobaWHVrOsC8 by jgnat: Correct formatting
CasperRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"

Welcome Alexia...

Wow, what a life you have led...  Thanks for sharing.

I can understand loving your Mother and not wanting to hurt her.   I have never been in your situation, many here have.  I am sure someone will come along that can share their experiences with you.

We look forward to getting to know you.

Cas

IP: gIRE2MDkL8LulYyY
darth frostyRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"

Guessing for paragraphs.

LONG story short: Forgive my grammar, I’m in a hurry! I grew up as a JW by my mother who was baptized about two years before I was born. My dad studied but was a severe (really severe) alcoholic and my older brother studied but was never really into it. She did not divorce him despite the alcoholism, verbal abuse, driving us children around while stone drunk and having minor accidents with us in the car (SOMONE was looking after us). The elders told her that that she had to remain with him. Years later when I was 16, he started using crack and steeling from the home and stole thousands of dollars out of my mom’s checking account one time. The brothers in this new congregation we started attending told her she can divorce and still be free to marry if she wanted (which after 27 years of Hell, she didn’t!).
 
I was sexually assaulted when I was 9-12 many times by some boys the went to a middle school. One of then just was the son of an elder. I told my mother and we went to the brothers and they pretty much blew me off because I didn’t “scream” like some account in the Bible were Taymor? Taimor? did or didn’t scream when was raped by her brother. I was scared to death during those years. I couldn’t run, let alone scream. My case was essentially dismissed by them. That has left a horrible scar on me.
 
I got baptized when I was 17. I didn’t know what I wanted out of life though. I had already started to slip away a couple years back, had boyfriends and sex, experimented with weed and alcohol (just occasionally), but still attended all meetings and FS because my mother was my influence. I pretty much got baptized for my mother. By 19-20, I really wanted to get married. Mostly because I wanted to stop committing fornication! At 20 I married a ministerial servant who I later found out didn’t want to work, wanted me to support him, owned guns (secretly but legally). I found out later that he had this horrible dark side that wanted to murder women. I know this sound odd but I was practically married to a potential serial killer. He said Jehovah was the only thing keeping him from acting out.
 
I stayed with him for three years. I supported him financially and emotionally. Then he started to physically abuse me. I woke up one night with his hands around my neck for no reason. We also had an argument where he attacked me in the same way. Stupidly, I didn’t leave him until 6 months later. When I told the elders why, they pretty much blew me off and asked why I didn’t tell them sooner. They didn’t believe me because I waited almost six months to report him. They didn’t ask me if I went to the police, filed a report or anything. I was told if I divorce, I wouldn’t be free to remarry. They never questioned him about his actions. That was the end of that discussion. This was summer of 2002. I left him, filed divorce, got my own place and never went to another meeting except the Memorial which I stopped going last year.
 
I’m in another relationship with a sane man and we have the upmost respect for each other. I had other relationships and flings but there were not long-term. This is.
 
So here is the problem: My mother, who is still very active in the congregation, knows nothing about this. “This” meaning my not attending meetings, not going to the memorials, I have no publications; she doesn’t know I have relationships, sex, nothing. I don’t want disassociate myself because I love my mother (despite her past faults) and it would crush her to know end. We are not very close but we talk about 2-3 a month by phone. Whenever she brings up the society, I pretend I know what she’s talking about. I get most of my information about what’s going on like the Watchtower changes and the new “Bible Study” arrangement from sites such as this one. Any advice? I know this is a hard one, but any experiences or words would help. If it wasnt for her, I would have DF myself long ago.
IP: WH6FPByM2Hc+YK+7
jamiebowersRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
Your story sounds very similar to mine, except I was df'd simply for refusing to bow to the will of the WTB&TS based on principle.  I did not want to hang around long enough to see if my crazy jw husband would either accomplish his death threats or commit adultery, freeing me to remarry.  There are many of us in the same situation.  But anyway, why do you have to do anything?  Are you planning to marry this man?  If so, why not marry him and not let your mom know?  Do you know that status of your ex?  Maybe he's already committed adultery, freeing you to remarry  If you're not ready to marry this guy, then why say anything to your mom?  Why say anything to her about him one way or the other? 
IP: xhZsrylSZNY/xXFg
Rev1212Re: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
So sorry for the bad things that happened to you.  But why didn't your mom call the police about the sexual assaults when you were between 9 and 12????  And what about when your husband was physically abusive to you -- why didn't YOU go to the police and have him arrested? The elders at the KH are not police chiefs that can go an arrest a perpetrator. Well I don't have all the facts and don't wish to put you down because obviously you have had a hard life, but whenever I have had problems regarding criminal matters, I have taken it to the police station, not to the Kingdom Hall. I don't see how the two places are even remotely related.
IP: 0I4MrG9zGdhy2GPU
jamiebowersRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"

whenever I have had problems regarding criminal matters, I have taken it to the police station, not to the Kingdom Hall. I don't see how the two places are even remotely related.

Because elders very seldom encourage outside involvement.  They don't consider abuse of women and children inside the organization as a crime that should be reported to the police but as a sin that should be reported to the elders.

IP: xhZsrylSZNY/xXFg
Rev1212Re: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"

I am still not understanding -- what would the elders have to do with a criminal matter?

Hello, if someone breaks into my house and steals stuff from me I am not going to go to an elder to report it. I am going to call the police. Same for if I were raped -- I would call the police, not the elders!

 

IP: 0I4MrG9zGdhy2GPU
thomRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
Sorry to hear alot of what has happened, but it sounds like you're with a good guy now, which is great! May family is mostly in, but I just stopped going to meetings about 5 years ago. No need to disassociate myself, I've not been disfellowshipped, I just quit. After a while, you're family figures it out and can be pushy, but my thought is that people need to do what's best for themselves, as long as you're not hurting anyone. I don't consider making your own spiritual decisions as hurting someone else, no matter how much they try to make you feel that way. At some point family will start saying "Why are you doing something that means I can't spend time with you?" Remember that it is NOT YOU doing this, it is them. It's hard, but you have a life to live and a right to live it. Note: I'd put paragraph breaks in but they don't show up. Sorry about that.
IP: 5jbVpHBr8gVd45aZ by thom: Correct formatting
AlexiaRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
"I am still not understanding -- what would the elders have to do with a criminal matter?" Of course they have nothing to do with a criminal matter. When this happened between me and my ex-husband, I was too afraid to go to the police. I _did_ have to explain to the elders why I was divorcing him. "But why didn't your mom call the police about the sexual assaults when you were between 9 and 12???? " She did, but they boys left the area (for a few years) when they found out they cops were after them. Thus, they got away with it. I have no idea what my ex is doing. I havent seen him or since before I filed for divorce.
IP: AayvCcj6VeKNR7Bd
AlexiaRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
Sorry about the lack of paragraphs and spacing. I cant figure out how to keep the proper spacing/paragraphs in the post when its published.
IP: AayvCcj6VeKNR7Bd
AlexiaRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
"I am still not understanding -- what would the elders have to do with a criminal matter?" Of course they have nothing to do with a criminal matter. When this happened between me and my ex-husband, I was too afraid to go to the police. I _did_ have to explain to the elders why I was divorcing him. "But why didn't your mom call the police about the sexual assaults when you were between 9 and 12???? " She did, but they boys left the area (for a few years) when they found out they cops were after them. Thus, they got away with it. I have no idea what my ex is doing. I havent seen him or since before I filed for divorce.
IP: AayvCcj6VeKNR7Bd
Tired of the HypocrisyRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"

First off, Welcome!

The elders are not qualified for anything is my personal experience with them. My wife insisted we call them over to discuss her daughter's issues. She was physically and sexually assaulting the middle child and had begun looking with an evil eye toward the newborn. It was determined that she needed a psychological evaluation and my wife asked that I call the elders.

They came, two of them. One of them is my wife's fleshly brother. They listened to the story and told us they could not tell us what to do, or even give us any guidance since this was a medical matter and they left. When the other elder left, my brother in law started in by telling me his opinion. How we BETTER NOT take her for an evaluation and blah blah blah, to pray and wait on jah to fix things.

I told him that I was not about to allow the other kids to suffer at her hands and would do what I had to do to make her well and protect the boys. He got all huffy and said that I better not take her to a psychiatrist or else. So I asked him if he wanted her in his house then, With his kids and he said no, so I told him that since him and his boe were impotent as a group that he should shut his mouth and keep it shut.

He got mad and left. What I pulled away from this is that they are not qualified for anything. So if I need a cop I call a cop. If I need a doctor I call a doctor. And if I need spiritual help I pray and never, ever call a jw!!

IP: RI3mDLgd/uHrZwf9 by Tired of the Hypocrisy: Correct spelling
LouBelleRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"

As some will testify too it's very difficult living, to use a JW term, a double life.  Do you think your mother would shun you?   or   if this is working for you, and your mum is non the wiser, can you continue the way you are?   or   is it that you want to make a stand against this faith?

You need to sit down and think what is best for you.  Sometimes we attached so much of who we are to other people (parents, spouse, children) that you shove what is best and healthy for you aside to please someone else.

Welcome to the board - hope you can come to a decision.

IP: NQieve1b9aGqtIHa
OnTheWayOutRe: Re: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
"I am still not understanding -- what would the elders have to do with a criminal matter?" Of course they have nothing to do with a criminal matter. When this happened between me and my ex-husband, I was too afraid to go to the police.

Don't dwell too much on Rev1212's response.  The vast majority of us understand why
you went to the elders and you gave a good response. 

It's a tough choice for you.  I don't confront my mother's JW world head-on.  Similarly to
you, I say very little.  My mother doesn't know the extent of my fade from the religion.
I am totally inactive, attending no meetings but my wife still attends.  I chose to just
answer any questions my mother asks, but not to volunteer any information.  One day,
she will ask about my meeting attendence.  She knows I stopped being an elder, she
knows I didn't go to the District Convention.  She knows something is wrong, but she is
afraid to ask too much.

You could decide to continue as things are.  You could decide to "confide" in Mom that
you haven't been going to the meetings.  You could do this by saying what your feelings
are about the poor help you received from the elders when you were abused by a JW
years ago, and by your husband.  You can say this in such a way that you don't totally
knock what Mom believes (doctrine) but just say that you were stumbled and cannot go
back. 

You could decide to an all-out honesty about everything.  That's a personal choice.
I am not sure that Mom could handle that and continue to talk with you.   You might lose
her to shunning, but usually when a child is not DF'ed, most Mom's keep talking to them.
You would know better than us what she might do.

Read everyone's thoughts.  We will offer differing advice because we are all different people
with different goals and feelings.  Ultimately, you will know better than us what is best for you.

IP: V6NggEvFWK/CdbTI
HortensiaRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
you go ahead and do what's best for you. It sounds as though your mother was on your side, although unfortunately she followed the direction of the elders. But hang out here too and get to know the folks here. You can get a lot of good advice and feedback, even if you don't agree with all of it.
IP: UmQrWvFC3BTa0rEk
Shawn10538Re: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
I wish you well. It sounds to me like you have never realy been a Witness. You have lived a double life from before during and after your baptism from what I read. You have never been really honest about who you are to your mother. Don't you want to not be a hypocrite just once in your life? Put milder, don't you want to be true to yourself for once in your life? you have your mother, but only by a lie. Do you really have her then? It sounds lke some co-dependency is going on there, not open, honest, unconditional love.

Then again you do have to realize that your mother is in a cult, and you are obviously not healed from being a cult member yourself. If you force a confrontation you will lose her - she will choose her religion over you. I have no doubt about that. But if you really take this time of indecision to educate yourself on the beliefs of JWs and what us critics have to say, you can craft an exit plan for yourself and your mother. You can start dropping subliminal messages on her and try to gradually undermine her faith. Don't feel bad about doing that if JWs are not the truth, she is living a lie herself. Help her to see the lies of the WT. Slowly. Also, you should become the best daughter you know how to be. Not by going to the meetings, but by really trying to connect with her in non-JW ways. help to create Non-JW good times that you both can share without lying to one another.
IP: zkNJraX8Ut6exGcn
owenfieldreamsRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"

Wow...interesting story.  Follow your intellect, not your heart--that would be my advice.

IP: n4+E/rWXfNuGmLyD
jwfactsRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
It sounds like what you are currently doing is working out fine. I went all out against the WTS and destroyed my family ties in the process. Other friends I grew up with keep their thoughts to themselves and it works a lot better. What you may want to do is let her know over time that you are no longer active, better she finds out from you than from others. Just make some excuse about work load or something, rather than admit you do not believe it. You mother has suffered a lot, and the hope of paradise is possibly what gives it all meaning. It may be best to leave that hope with her due to her age.
IP: ZTgR75rhGuKzOKTe
AlexiaRe: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
Thank you everyone for your thoughtful responses. I didn't expect the elders to send my ex husband to jail, but I did expect them to at least ask him about it - they didn't. Later, I learned the society doesn't acknowledge sexual abuse, rape, domestic, child abuse, etc. In terms of my mother, its been years since I been back to the meetings. I do have to think about whats best for and and for her as well. It would be harder if we were closer. If we get married and/or decide to have a baby, then she will need to know about all of this. I'm not concerned about the congregations, my only concern is my mother. She will shun me, try to get me back in and grieve because according to her, she will have no family members who will survive Armageddon since she is the only one who is in "the truth". I am her only hope. (Sorry again about the lack of paragraphs. I havent figured out this forum yet)
IP: AayvCcj6VeKNR7Bd
AlexiaRe: Re: Not sure what to do - Not "in" and not "out"
And though I was never "really" a Witness, I still believed it. I couldn't control some of my urges. I definitely though I was going to be destroyed if I didnt straighten up and fly right. Feeling trapped in that way was definitely one reason why I stupidly got married, ha ha!
IP: AayvCcj6VeKNR7Bd