Hi Kenneson,
Regarding the Rutherford-Troy Debate, you might find it helpful to read the entire script. Bill Cetnar made it available in TROY DEBATES RUTHERFORD (privately published). I think that you can still order a copy from:
Cetnar
Route 3 Weir Lake Road
Kunkletown, PA 18058
The late Bill Cetnar assembled the information from the Los Angeles Express which covered the debate in great detail. Bill Cetnar makes this interesting observation in the book's forward: "At a Bethel meeting I sat next to John Adam Baeurlein a former International Director and Officer of the Watchtower Society. He mentioned he had attended the Rutherford-Troy debates. I asked him why the Society refused to debate today. He answered: 'Because Rutherford lost his shirt in debate with Troy.' He then added: 'The Watchtower is not God's Organization.' These remarks from this old man who spent 50 years at Watchtower Headquarters were a shock to me."