MemberPostViewed: times
dmouseI need advice quick...and a hug.

I'm in a bit of a state at the moment, my wife has just left me about 30 mins ago and took the kids...I don't know where...

OK, some of you long-timers may remember the problems I had with my son Ben, who decided that the JW religion wasn't for him about a year ago. I supported him as best I could through that and he's developed into a fine young man with a more healthy spiritual attitude, investigationg a number of Christian Churches in the area and finally settled on Church of England, which he really likes now.

Although no longer a Christian myself I have no objection to them pursuing whatever religious path they choose (obviously within reason). That has been the case with all of my children: Ben, 15, Charlotte, 14 and Chloe, 12. I have NEVER attempted to stop my wife taking them to the meetings although I have voiced to them privately my concerns about the religion. But I have had nowhere near the input into their spiritual development that my wife has.

She is a devout JW and this morning things came to a head. Charlotte has for some time been expressing to me that she doesn't believe the JW religion is the Truth anymore and really hates going. This morning, out of the blue, she told her mum that she will not go to anymore meetings. My wife got really angry. She was screaming and shouting at Charlotte, physically forcing her to get changed for the meeting, and shouting at me for 'killing the children' and how much of a bad father I was and she hated me.

I didn't know what to do

Eventually I could see that Charlotte was getting really distressed so I stepped in and told my wife that it was OK to take Cahrlotte to the meetings if she could be pursuaded through normal means but I was not going to allow her to be bullied, either through emotional blackmail or physical intervention.

My wife went ballistic and told me that if I didn't back down she would take legel action against me! She told me she had been recording things, writing them down!! (I don't know what). She was going to get me kicked out of the house.

Anyway, I stayed as calm as I could for the kids, I didn't even raise my voice even though my wife was screaming at me.

But I stuck to my guns and said that I would not let her force the children to go to a place they hated day after day week after week.

So she grabbed the girls, who were sobbing, and left in the car. Charlotte didn't even have any shoes on...

I haven't a clue where she's gone (I'm hoping her JW mother's), I didn't dare physically intervene, I just don't know where I stand on this and didn't want to make things worse.

So I'm left shaking and bewildered in an empty house wondering what the hell is going to happen and I don't know what to do.

Dean.
IP: gEO79ozG3X3Z/HE6
moonwillowRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.
Oh Dean gives you a big hug I hope it all works out for you if you need someoen to talk to pm me.
IP: lIEdEPUyeqfMfvil
ScullyRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

((((((((((((( Dean ))))))))))))) I'm so sorry you're going through this.

Would they be going to the meeting?  As much as I hate the idea of setting foot in a KH ever again, in this instance I think it's worth going there to make sure your children are safe.

Since it's obvious that she's taking steps to eventually get the marriage dissolved, you had better start documenting incidents (like this one) and get yourself to a lawyer and get some advice.  You shouldn't have to tolerate her saying things like "You are killing the children" nor should the children EVER be subjected to those opinions of you.

Love, Scully
IP: EgbGll6YpZznPSde
minimusRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.
Dean.....I feel SO bad for you. Your wife is losing CONTROL. It's even slipping with her children. She's angry and doesn't know what to do and probably got some "advice" to do these things. Try to reason with her and you might need to compromise. A judge could see it that way too. Try to find out why she's so angry. It seems that everytime another family member leaves, she feels more by herself. Coddle her, if you can.
IP: 7PJYRKnnStopBzgn
frenchbabyfaceRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.
((()))
IP: zjLHIhTgCmCXcyfd
gumbyRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

Well dean......your wife has lost it......not you........please remember that.

JWism has a way of making a person feel they are the blame for things........enen though YOU know it's the religion that is the root of the problem.

Your wife has no recourse against you to "take action" as she has stated. Take action for what?

Everyone of your kids can testify you have been passive with your wife and her religious freedom ....as well as your children. I think this last little stint of hers will solidify your kids attitude about her  ......and her beliefs. I think that you have stayed cool through all this is Amazing and you deserve a pat on the back.

I don't know how long you two have been together and love each other but hopefully you can work this out without legal battles and solve it somehow.

A big hug from gumby........PM me if you need to talk more to someone.

Gumby
IP: rccEo/psXotlpryE
ScullyRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

(((((((((((((( Dean )))))))))))))))))) another hug because I think you need it!

You are a teacher, so you must know what the rules and regulations are regarding child abuse in your jurisdiction.

I think you and your wife need to meet with a counsellor from Family Services / Child Welfare (or whatever the official agency is in your area).  Your wife is totally out of line being verbally and physically abusive with the children.  She is being unreasonable in insisting that the girls continue to go to the KH against their will.  It will only make the girls dig in their heels and resist even more if they see their mother getting even more insistent and unreasonable.

I agree with Minimus that she is terrified that she is losing control over the children.  To her mind, it reflects on her own inadequacy to "bring them up in the discipline and mental regulating of Jehovah".  Rather than admitting her own inadequacy or even worse to her way of thinking the inadequacy of the JW belief system to retain its youth, she chooses to use you as a scapegoat.

Bottom line: she is being abusive.  To you, and to the children.  Deal with her the way you would if she was the mother of one of your students who was confiding in you about things in their own home.

Love, Scully
IP: EgbGll6YpZznPSde
DannyBearRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

Dean,

Iam with Gumby on this. In fact keep a printed copy of this story, it should work wonders with any Judge worth his robes.

To allow religion to upset children in this manner is worse than anything she may have written down about your supposed sins.

Sometimes fanatics bury themselves, without even realizing. My ex jw wife did so in our divorce. She acted like an ass, and the judge saw through it. He ended up giving her nothing she asked for, then proceeded to award the minimum amount of child support. All because she thought she was on 'gods' side.

So take heart my friend, its not always as bad as it seems.

Danny
IP: w4hO5SJCZHNQkirX
dmouseRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

Thanks so much for all the support friends, it means a lot to me.

Scully, I'm going to walk round to her mother's now and see if the car is there, so at least I know they are somewhere safe. If not then I'll have to get my bike out of mothballs and go up to the hall.

L8r

Dean
IP: gEO79ozG3X3Z/HE6
AztecRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

(((Dean))) Wow! She is being emotionally abusive to you and your children. Emotional abuse is even worse than physical abuse! Trust me on this, cause I know. Document everything. Write it down while it's still fresh in your mind. I don't know what the laws are like there so I'll refrain from giving any kind of legal advice but, make notes of everything. Much luck to you!

~Aztec
IP: XbznN4/AdLoXVnbq
shotgunRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

Dean I'm so sorry...Been there buddy and it hurts like hell.

You are my hero for the excellent stand you made, you took the high road and believe me the kids are aware of it. Sounds to me like your predicament is worse than mine.....I'm not sure what she could mean about taped conversations......It may sound scary but under certain circumstances the elders will back her for seperation or divorce on the grounds of spiritual endangerment...but you seem to be willing to let the kids go to the synagogue with her if they want.

I'll keep bumping you to the top buddy and maybe someone can offer better solice and encouragement than me.

My thoughts are with you

 
IP: IsdbO6vJSNcFGjqi
dmouseRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

Phew! The car is outside her mother's (five minutes walk away) so at least I know they are somewhere safe.

Scully, I suggested to my wife about seeing a professional marriage counselor a few months ago but she didn't seem keen. She said she would think about it but we never mentioned it again. You know what JWs feel about such agencies; regular meeting attendance, field service and study solve ALL problems.
I agree with Minimus that she is terrified that she is losing control over the children.  To her mind, it reflects on her own inadequacy to "bring them up in the discipline and mental regulating of Jehovah".  Rather than admitting her own inadequacy or even worse to her way of thinking the inadequacy of the JW belief system to retain its youth, she chooses to use you as a scapegoat.

I think that's it, yes. Things were never the same between us after Ben left the religion. That was the turning point when our relationship just sort of stopped. I tried for ages to carry on with a normal marriage but she turned utterly cold towards me. No physical or emotional affection at all has been expressed towards me by her since about a year last Christmas.

It's Sunday, so I can't take any legal advice today.

I'm hoping that it won't come to that and it'll all blow over. I can hope can't I?

Wonder if I'll get a visit from the elders? I wonder what they will advise her?
IP: gEO79ozG3X3Z/HE6
Lady LeeRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

Dean I don't know about the laws in England but in Canada if your name is on the house papers she can't have you thrown out. Check with a lawyer. Some places have a free legal info line. Check your phone book. Odd as it sounds try calling a women's shelter. They might be helpful.

Also at the ages of the children they might be given a choice of which parent they want to live with. Here a child over the age of 14 gets to choose. So don't worry about what she might have on you. The incident today was clearly abusive.

Be strong and loving with the children. You have rights. Find out what they are and use them to the full to protect yourself and the children
IP: OjixSJEiIY/Tmb7O by Lady Lee: Correct formatting
Stacy SmithRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

I can't imagine my mom dragging me out of the house like that to make a meeting.  But if you want your kids out of the dubs then mom has helped your side.  You were behaving as a "christian" should behave, it sounds like, and what was she behaving like?  Someone insane?
I think you and your wife need to meet with a counsellor from Family Services / Child Welfare (or whatever the official agency is in your area).

I suspect she's only going to be willing to meet with elders.  After all we all know how well elders are educated. 

 
IP: E7W5rjCBkh6EH5UQ
arrowstarRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

(((((Dean)))))

I'm so sorry that you are going through this pain. 

Seek legal counsel as soon as possible.  Make sure the children are safe at all times.  Protect yourself.

Lisa
IP: YTwv6u5WU63BXjEN
Stacy SmithRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.
Wonder if I'll get a visit from the elders? I wonder what they will advise her?

I would think they'll advise her to respect Jehovahs headship arrangement right? 

This would be an interesting visit from the elders.  You know the rules and they know you know them.  The most they could say is if you were more spiritual your wife would respect you and the arrangment more. 

She blew it bigtime.  Are you having serious thoughts of divorce?

 
IP: E7W5rjCBkh6EH5UQ
nilfunRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

Wow, Dmouse, I'm so sorry you and your children are experiencing such abuse.  Hats off to you for taking the high road! 

It seems that your wife has already been preparing herself for a divorce (?) so I can't agree enough with the others who have advised you to seek legal counsel A.S.A.P.  You just might be in for the fight of your life.

((Dmouse))
IP: Nl3zuXljJPnR9NwY
closer2fineRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

(((((Hugs))))) I'm glad to hear they are safe at her mothers. - at least she didn't head to the hall.  I don't know if you posted it before, but is her mom a JW?

 

closer
IP: G95zDHRdYPiVToYY
Big TexRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

I second Lady Lee's excellent advice.  The laws in the U.S. are similar.  To protect yourself, and the children, consulting with a lawyer would be a great idea.  You need to know what your rights are.

As for the elders, they almost certainly will visit you to "encourage" you.  When that happens take control and do not let them pepper you with questions.  Over here the Witnesses are scared of media attention, so perhaps a well chosen word or two about going to the media might cause them to back off.

I'm very sorry you're going through this Dean.  Your wife should not put her children in a situation where they must choose between the two of you.  If possible give Charlotte an avenue to talk to you and express how she's feeling.  Give them support as they must be terribly frightened right now.

Best advice ever given to me was this:    >breathe in<  >breathe out<

Take it one day at a time Dean.

Be well,

Chris
IP: NxH8Nx7fk6FCaOPz
berylblueRe: I need advice quick...and a hug.

Dean, I am so sorry.

You know, happy, content persons do not act like that.  Content persons simply do not go around screaming and threatening. Your wife is extremely unhappy.  The question is, "why"?  Do you think being in the borg has anything to do with it? 

In retrospect, I can see where I myself was pretty lunatic at times due to the pressures of trying to be a good little JW.

I really don't have any sage advice; I will leave that to those here who excel at that.
IP: U/Mo2B658fjrIrAG