MemberPostViewed: times
StillinLove  How to make love & marriage work w/a JW


Please dont comment saying to "run" or "get out while I can" thank you Im not new to this, so I can handel it. I have been with my boyfriend for 3 years, we started dating in high school and now I am going to college and he is working. I am 20 and he is 21, I was raised catholic but my mom and I are too open minded for the church so we left. He is a JW, him and his friends had always dated (almost always worldly girls) and hid it from thier parents and their congregation. Thats how he said it always is, the kids just sort of sneek around and have a very good system too. I know that he always wanted me to convert and tried to get me to and he always will, but when we discuss religion (which is often) I am never swayed and he has gotten used to it. And as he explained it; life would be much easier for us if we were both JW and obviously he would want me to be one b/c of his beleif about paradise earth. But thats not a big deal b/c he loves me regardless of my beleifs and we're very feisty so we actually have a pretty good time debating our differences.

So my concerns are; his religousness has made him incredibly small minded in certain ways and I am concerned about how that will affect our ability to raise kids. I am totally fine with them being raised as witnesses because he is an incredible person with strong values from his faith and I am not religous so I know that it is more important to him than me. BUT i do however want my kids to learn about other cultures, make friends with whoever they want, be allowed to date, and not ever be put in a position where they have to lie like he always has. What can i expect from him, and how can I ease the tension?

The other issue is that from what I know (which is alot at this point) from him and the watchtower website they are pretty sexist. “My husband exercises his headship in a loving and kind way,” says Susan. “We usually discuss decisions, and when he decides what will or will not be done, I know it is for our benefit. Jehovah’s arrangement for Christian wives really makes me happy" is from the website and pretty much says it all. I am incredibly headstrong and dont give a damn what the bible says because I dont follow it, so I wont be following that model. Problem being: how do I get him to understand that Im not that kind of woman and dont want to be? I want to get him to realize that we need to be able to work together as equals and he needs to back down on that one? He understands my side but says "thats what the bible says so..." so my question is how do i get him to get over that and compermise?

IP: eFNdmqm2YClqt97x
jgnatRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

Hi, we have so much in common. I was with my first husband from when I was a teenager, too. I am married to a Witness now.

I'm curious why he is bothering to try and convert you. Has he ever introduced you to his family? He's not supposed to be living common-law. Even if you converted, he is still in bad standing with the congregation to be living with you, unmarried.

So my concerns are; his religousness has made him incredibly small minded in certain ways and I am concerned about how that will affect our ability to raise kids

You got that right. I would not raise children together with my JW husband, for the very reason you mentioned. I would not raise a child to think that they have to sneak around on their parents, be afraid of judgement, and judge others as unworthy of paradise. I love both my children, from my first marriage, equally, and I would do it no other way. The only way I can see to ease the tension is to agree not to have children together. Or else get him to agree to visit nondenominational churches to broaden his mind first.

I see your boyfriend has tried to "exercise his headship" over you. I don't allow such nonsense either, because of my abusive first marriage. H handel my husband very well. To my advantage I know the bible very well and I am an accomplished debater. I can give plenty of examples of strong, independent women in the bible. If he ever brings up a bible principle again, remind him he is he's separated from Jehovah because he has not formalized his commitment to you before God and the civil authorities. He's fornicating. Right back atcha, mister.

As for paradise earth, ask him how he thinks he knows you won't be there? You have a very confused young man.

IP: fOu2RQWWW+YlipQM by jgnat: Correct formatting
still_in74Re: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

He is a JW, him and his friends had always dated (almost always worldly girls) and hid it from thier parents and their congregation.
I know that he always wanted me to convert and tried to get me to and he always will, but when we discuss religion (which is often) I am never swayed and he has gotten used to it.
And as he explained it; life would be much easier for us if we were both JW and obviously he would want me to be one b/c of his beleif about paradise earth.

So my concerns are; his religousness has made him incredibly small minded in certain ways and I am concerned about how that will affect our ability to raise kids.
I am totally fine with them being raised as witnesses because he is an incredible person with strong values from his faith and I am not religous so I know that it is more important to him than me. BUT i do however want my kids to learn about other cultures, make friends with whoever they want, be allowed to date, and not ever be put in a position where they have to lie like he always has.

The other issue is that from what I know (which is alot at this point) from him and the watchtower website they are pretty sexist. “My husband exercises his headship in a loving and kind way,” says Susan. “We usually discuss decisions, and when he decides what will or will not be done, I know it is for our benefit. Jehovah’s arrangement for Christian wives really makes me happy" is from the website and pretty much says it all. I am incredibly headstrong and dont give a damn what the bible says because I dont follow it, so I wont be following that model. Problem being: how do I get him to understand that Im not that kind of woman and dont want to be? I want to get him to realize that we need to be able to work together as equals and he needs to back down on that one? He understands my side but says "thats what the bible says so..." so my question is how do i get him to get over that and compermise?

Hi and welcome to the board.
as for your situation - my mother was a JW and my father was not. This caused some tension between my mother and her in-laws but she was very stubborn and controlling. Had she been a little more "flexible" with them it may not have been as difficult.
As for my parents, they seemed to be alright although my father was pretty easy going. He also enjoyed the company of the JW's in the cong. and they all like him - so that helped.
This division certainly caused more tension for my mother as she was always playing the "unbelieving husband" card and always trying to get him to convert. She eventually resented the fact he would not become a JW but then things settled down once us kids were all older. But certainly the home environment was not one I would want for my children - I did not like being around the house.
As for your comments above - regarding kids sneaking around - some do/did but not all. Many of us (like myself) actually were pretty good in this area, although now I regret not having a bit more fun in my youth when I had an excuse for doing it!
Regarding kids, i know many kids that were raised in similar households. They tend to take "the truth", or go the other direction but maintane many of their JW friends as they had never been baptized. This actually works well for them as they get the best of both worlds. This of course is for children that are confident in themselves and do not have self-esteem issues. If so, then they may struggle with feelings of worthlessness.
I myself am fearful to have children as my wife is an active JW and I am still-in but no longer recognize the WTS as gods chosen channel.
Regarding the org being sexist. Those articles are written by old men!Almost EVERYONE knows that that is not the real world. Husbands and wives typically find a system that works for them. Most husbands know that the "loving your wife as you love yourself" bit is where it really counts.
Husbands that "dominate" their wives are usually the ones the most people dont like to be around. Often the wives are noticabley different from the rest. Those marriages tend to fail.
Your husband actually sounds more open minded than you think. You should really get settled into your "religious" paths before bringing children into the mix - at least this way you both know where stand in that regard and it will be less frustrating for them. Certainly though - this type of childhood is frustrating - I know, I lived it.
Best of luck
Still..................
IP: V1XNH/vZzJ7xS4tQ by still_in74: Correct formatting
OnTheWayOutRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW
Please dont comment saying to "run" or "get out while I can"

So there's not much else to say.  You know better what you want, so figure it out for yourself.
I will say much anyway.

Seriously, welcome.  I understand your question, but you gotta understand why we would
say "Run."  He is a weak JW to date you, but he may decide to become a strong JW one day.
but when we discuss religion (which is often) I am never swayed and he has gotten used to it.

So he is always going to look down on your lack of acceptance of his beliefs and you may
always look down on his beliefs.  That's a rough way to start a marriage.

And as he explained it; life would be much easier for us if we were both JW

That's his way of already asserting that the problem is with you.  Life would be easier if
HE got out of the JW's instead of remaining one and disobeying their general directive to
"marry only in the lord" and to date JW's only with the intent of marrying one of them.

our ability to raise kids. I am totally fine with them being raised as witnesses because he is an incredible person with strong values from his faith and I am not religous so I know that it is more important to him than me.

It's not about what's important to you.  The kids will be raised as JW's to be taught that
Mommie is "wrong" or "worldly" or any number of negative terms like "going to be destroyed
at Armageddon."  They will be taught an unhealthy fear of a God who uses the WT organization
to control people.  They will miss out on normal activities such as interaction with other kids
concerning holidays and birthdays- they might be fearful that Jehovah will destroy them if they
wear green on St. Patricks Day or accept a piece of birthday cake from a five-year-old.  They
will be expected to go to all those meetings that reinforce the doctrine down their throats and
teaches them that Mommie deserves to be destroyed, along with that five-year-old that tried
to give them cake.  They will be expected to skip sports and college and set their goals toward
selling WT literature full time for free and working part-time to stay poor and barely get by.

But, hey- it doesn't matter to YOU.

Your future husband will likely take his religion seriously one day, especially after he has kids
or after his elders or higher ups tell him why he is not pleasing Jehovah.

how do I get him to understand that Im not that kind of woman and dont want to be? I want to get him to realize that we need to be able to work together as equals and he needs to back down on that one? He understands my side but says "thats what the bible says so..."
So, like many single people, you are in love but you want to change the other person.  That
headship thing is ingrained in them, so there's no hope there sister.  Live with it or RUN.
IP: V6NggEvFWK/CdbTI
Jim_TXRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

Wow... I think you have a lot to think about.

Especiall if you decide you want to marry this fella. Him being a JW - you DO realize that he will not be celebrating any holidays. No birthdays... no mother's - or father's days... no thanksgivings... no christmas... and so on.

I say this because... you mentioned having children. They will not be allowed to celebrate these holidays... as he will 'lead' the household and forbid it as a JW.

Wow... I was raised a JW... and was always on the outside - looking in - at the families that were not JWs - and were having fun celebrating their holidays.

Oh - and I didn't mention the 'blood' issue... if you are in the hospital - giving birth - and something goes wrong... will he support you - and allow you to accept blood - if you need it? (A poor example, perhaps - but you may get the point.) The same goes for any children you have. If they ever need blood - will he allow it? Probably not - as a JW.

It's your decision... I just hope that you think it through - all the way.

Good Luck.

Regards,

Jim TX

IP: N8bLe5TtbRKZAaIH
OnTheWayOutRe: Re: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW
Oh, and one day, maybe the husband will be expected to totally shun his own
adult children because they don't accept his religion after they got baptized as
pre-teens, or maybe they will shun him because they did accept it, but Daddy
wised up and left the WT organization. 
IP: V6NggEvFWK/CdbTI
Open mindRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

For the sake of brevity, I'll just slightly change the name of this thread to:

How to make love to a JW on the sand.

It can be done.  In fact, if you're both very careful, it could actually be enjoyable. 

But if either of you wiggles too much (imposes your beliefs on the other) or the wind (family, elders) kicks up, the friction could be a deal breaker.

Open Mind

IP: c9GfOyFfUtQ4sA+y
ninjaRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW
don't make love to your woman on the sand...your child could turn out to be one son of a beach
IP: 0U0EBh5oXKm7KOEg
Open mindRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

*for da ninjster*

BADA - BOOM!

 

IP: PSTJz8kTvfJ9TVik
sacoltonRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

Oh, to be young and naive again ... *sigh*

First of all, you'll have to understand that he will obey Jehovah first. I'm not saying "He is obedient to God first", but his loyality to the Watchtower and the doctrines that come from the Governing Body. Depending on his goals as a Jehovah's Witness - if he wishes to become an elder or reach for higher ranks within the organization - his advancement will be greatly restricted because of his "worldly" wife. It will be seen as him being "weak" because he did not marry "in the truth", so he may (or may not) try to get you to conform.

It's all about conformity.

Love means you should NEVER have to change yourself to please another. I think you should continue researching and weigh the pros and cons before making a decision. It won't be easy to live in a split-faith relationship. No holidays or birthdays for the kids. It's a very dull lifestyle with the only excitement being the Memorial and wedding anniverseries.

Take a step back and look at the big picture ... see yourself 20 years from now ...

IP: AZRAf/Yh2QUpg1DP by sacolton: Correct formatting
dinahRe: Re: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

Run!  (sorry couldn't resist)

 

IP: GbcgBsiUyZe0FCyQ
Quirky1Re: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

Welcome Stillinlove - There is not much I can say that others haven't.  I will tell you it will be a difficult road to travel.  If you and your mother were "too" open minded for the Catholics then you sre in for a rude awakening.  That is why your boyfreind is small minded.  The JW religion controls that portion of their life and their thinking.

Now, you do not mind if your children are witnesses but you want them to experience other cultures, dating and soforth.  This may be difficult being in a religion that is very controlling regarding these issues.

This even speaks as far as headship is concerned. As OTWO mentioned, he may be a "strong" JW someday and this will put a bump in the relationship if you are as strongminded as you say you are. Or, if you become a JW and submit to the mind contolled brain washing effects it may not bother you.

You have to think this completely thru yourself.  I suggest "Do your research about the religion" before you commit to anything.  

Quirky1

IP: 5vqU68bliuL+iqdK
95stormfrontRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW
Please dont comment saying to "run" or "get out while I can" thank you Im not new to this, so I can handel it. I have been with my boyfriend for 3 years, we started dating in high school and now I am going to college and he is working. I am 20 and he is 21,

20, 21....Oh the naivete' of those years. How I wish I could live them all over again with the knowledge I have now.

He is a JW, him and his friends had always dated (almost always worldly girls) and hid it from thier parents and their congregation. Thats how he said it always is, the kids just sort of sneek around and have a very good system too.

What a way to live......to subject yourself to being the little piece on the side hidden away from all the important people in his life he would call his "friends".....good enough to get his rocks off into occasionally, but, not quite good enough to be presented with any degree of respect to the more important people in his life.

I'm sorry to be so brusk, but, twenty years from now when you're thinking about what you've written and how this guy is treating you, you're going to kick yourself in the head.

This is the typical "sowing wild oats" game JW males play. They run around using all those "worldly girls" for sexual playthings under the cover of darkness, then when their finally serious, drop them like hot potatoes for that virtuous 17 or 18 year old JW girl whose eye they caught when they're making positional progress in the organization.

What a smooth operator this guy must be.....what did he tell you to convince you to lower your self-respect to such a degree that he can get to have his cake, eat it too, and claim the religious moral high ground that things would be so much better if you'd come around to his way of thinking JW style.

But thats not a big deal b/c he loves me regardless of my beleifs and we're very feisty so we actually have a pretty good time debating our differences.

Marry this guy, wait around till he decides he wants to go full-throttle into the JW lifestyle and watch these "pretty good times" disappear, as more pressure than ever will be applied to you to conform. That's a promise.

So my concerns are; his religousness has made him incredibly small minded in certain ways and I am concerned about how that will affect our ability to raise kids. I am totally fine with them being raised as witnesses because he is an incredible person with strong values from his faith and I am not religous so I know that it is more important to him than me. BUT i do however want my kids to learn about other cultures, make friends with whoever they want, be allowed to date, and not ever be put in a position where they have to lie like he always has. What can i expect from him, and how can I ease the tension?

Just this recognition on your part gives promise that there's hope for you yet.

Let's see......he says he's in love with you while at the same time ashamed to present you as an equal amongst his JW brethren....he's sneaking around with you, going against the counsel he knows of being unevenly yoked. If you've been intimate, he's having sex without the benefit of marriage legally or scripturally, and has been doing this for awhile now, even to the point of you yourself expounding on this great "system" he and his friends have in place of justifying his two-face-ness. This guys whole approach towards you reeks of a selfish person who's "systemized" lying and hypocritical activity to a fine art, justifying it any way he can, and hoodwinking others to follow along as long as it's of benefit to him.

[SARCASM ON]

I AM IN AWE OF THE STRONG VALUES HE'S SHOWING FROM HIS FAITH!!!!!!

[/SARCASM OFF]

If you want your kids to do all those things you say you do, then I'd suggest you worry not so much about what is important to him or yourself, especially in trying to overlook what you're seeing with your own eyes, and concentrate on what's important to them. Marry this guy and as he positions himself for upward mobility within the congregation and WT heirarchy, this tension you're already facing will only increase.

The other issue is that from what I know (which is alot at this point) from him and the watchtower website they are pretty sexist. “My husband exercises his headship in a loving and kind way,” says Susan. “We usually discuss decisions, and when he decides what will or will not be done, I know it is for our benefit. Jehovah’s arrangement for Christian wives really makes me happy" is from the website and pretty much says it all. I am incredibly headstrong and dont give a damn what the bible says because I dont follow it, so I wont be following that model. Problem being: how do I get him to understand that Im not that kind of woman and dont want to be? I want to get him to realize that we need to be able to work together as equals and he needs to back down on that one? He understands my side but says "thats what the bible says so..." so my question is how do i get him to get over that and compermise?
You can see for yourself, even now, that he's trying to impose upon you without compromise his "my biblical authority" game. If you think it's going to get any easier after marriage, children, and his subsequent working for position within the WT, and you're as headstrong as you say you are, you're playing with fire and you're gonna get burnt.
 
But, you've already stated that you don't want to hear "run" or "get out while you can". So, I guess it's only a matter of time before you're back here with a tale of woe, willing to lend to a future generation the benefit of this particular experience.
IP: 730re5mHegC0bcGS by 95stormfront: Correct formatting
MeneMeneRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW
I suggest "Do your research about the religion" before you commit to anything.

That is the most important thing we can tell you.  Then make your own decision as to whether you want to be involved with the Watchtower Bible & Tract Society.

Here's a start.  http://www.watchtowerdocuments.com/   Make sure you read the Commentary.  It is available now for free on the website and is only about 100 pages.  Click on the link below the picture on the left side of the screen for the Commentary. 

 

Links for info on the blood issue:

http://www.ajwrb.org/

http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/16/150613/1.ashx

http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/16/149428/1.ashx

The blood issue is important and could cost you your life as well as the lives of your children.

Please read this and all the other info you can get your hands on so that you truly understand what you are getting yourself into.

 

IP: omSeOtIGq+IYhaVr
BalsamRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

Stillinlove,

The blood policy will be a huge problem if you have children.  It can be for you too if you ever need it and your husband refuses it for you even though your not a JW.  What is his stand on the blood policy? 

Ruth

IP: ISY4ovNMFT6WIb4f
flipperRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

STILL IN LOVE- Welcome to the board friend. You certainly do have a dilemma don't you ? Well, all I can say is I was married to a witness woman for 19 years - and nothing I did in the way of being nice, normal, or polite was ever enough for her. Witnesses are trained to judge you and have an opinion on you - based only on what they are told by the Watchtower society , not the Bible. It is a "patriarchal" system they believe in - and you are right the men are told to be " heads " of their family - so if you are an independent woman , that will not set well with you . Your husband will be trained by the Witnesses to not treat you as equal, but inferior , especially mentally. It is how they roll.

For the sake of any future children you would have with this man - Be informed that at their Service Meeting in September of 2007 , they were told to ONLY READ the Watchtower societies publications when doing research on things important to them . So this might explain why you have good reason to see your boyfriend is " narrow minded". They aren't allowed outside research other than the witness info ! So- you can see you won't get any input from him if you want to raise your children with cultural experiences and be learning about different cultures.

So- these are a few things to consider. As you stated , it certainly is your choice to pursue a long term with him- but I guarantee you - you will be forced to make more sacrifices for him , than he will be willing to make for you. The Jehovah's Witness religion is one that traps, imprisons, and controls it's members from outside influences - even their non-believing wives or husbands. So think carefully about your decisions friend, we are always here on the board if you want to vent or talk ! Peace out, Mr. Flipper
IP: 1fPwywKYavmp/o5a
VoidEaterRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

There are no "strong" open-minded, compromising JWs.  If they are open-minded, or compromising, they are breaking their faith.

Or does he just call himself a JW for the sake of family?

There are also those JWs that are good people...but that also dismiss much of the dogma as silly.  Maybe they are "weak" JWs.

JG being one of the stellar exceptions to oil and water not mixing (she is also wise, caring and good), there is little hope that you will have a smooth marriage unless you convert, or he unconverts.  Your mileage could vary - but I've seen the ashes of these relationships too often.  The attempted suicide of a cousin comes to mind.

so my question is how do i get him to get over that and compermise?

Couples counseling, BEFORE the wedding.  Write out a contract of how your kids will be raised, what he will do to become more balanced, what you will do to appease him.  And be prepared that his view of God's will may trump that at any time.

Other than that, I'm sorry to say that your query is along the lines of, "How can I have a safe relationship with a poisonous snake, without removing it's poison?"  Do the homework up front, or be constantly vigilent and always prepared for a fight.

Just my experience...

The only other comments - Welcome to the Board!

And...I am confused why you find his strong morals so inviting - isn't he breaking those morals to date you?

IP: bIqSkTfJRt7P+Wbl
Awakened at GileadRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

Hi Still in ,

I am a xJW married to a JW wife (14 years) and some days it seems like we will make it and some days it doesn't...

That being said, my main concern is that this guy is a liar... he's not even an honest JW. If he lies to his family, lies to his friends, lies to his religion, and lies to you (yes he lies to you), how can you trust him. And according to official JW belief, he doesn't stand a chance to get to paradise since they teach that any who commit fornication are destined for the lake of fire... not paradise on earth.

Please wake up and see this guy for the pathological liar that he is.

You may be now but that's better than being with a bunch of kids and more problems to boot.

IMHO

A@G

IP: Xu/uNFVnyLUlpBcc
4myloveRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

I wish you all the luck, you will need it. May will be my 3rd year anniversary to my inactive JW hubby. Even though he is inactive, the indoctrination runs deep for years. Tread very lightly, you will have to. I'm very open minded, which is probably what got me in this situation in the first place. My husband is worth the struggle, but, I would never want a family member to go through the fear of losing their loved one on a daily basis.

PLEASE sit down, talk it out, and ask him to be blatently honest as to what your relationship would truly be after marriage.

DO NOT BECOME YET ANOTHER SLAVE TO THIS CULT!!!!!

4

 

IP: T8Fat8cGlTbedw8E
jgnatRe: How to make love & marriage work w/a JW

After a little think, I've come up with an analogy to your request. It's like you've asked a bunch of cooks for a cake recipe without flour. And you've pre-warned us that you won't take "no" for an answer. You want you cake, and you want it the way you want it. Very well. You do have some options. Here are a couple, and they are quite yummy.

http://www.barry-callebaut.com/2274

Banana Nut Cake Without Flour

BUT if you then asked if you could have your cake without flour but you want it to be as light and fluffy as your mommy used to make, I'd say no. There are limits on what you can produce with your ingredients.

IP: l9+YCRGA9s4+GsIf