MemberPostViewed: times
ScullyDoes Your Family Eat Dinner Together?


Interesting article from today's National Post:

We don't eat together, and are paying for it
Families in crisis: Researchers say suppers apart may cause social ills
 
Misty Harris
CanWest News Service

Family dinner hour, once an institution in Canadian homes, is becoming a quaint relic among time-starved parents and kids. This according to at least a half-dozen recent reports from top universities, research firms and think-tanks, all of which paint a picture of families in crisis at the dinner table.

Or, more accurately, away from it.

The latest studies -- one from from Harvard Medical School, the other from Columbia University -- cite the family-dinner deficit as a contributing factor in childhood obesity, teen substance abuse, poor academic performance and increased household stress.

The problem has apparently grown to such proportions that a Canadian company -- with written support from Prime Minister Paul Martin, no less -- is organizing the country's first National Family Dinner Night. M & M Meat Shops is asking parents to make pledges on its Web site to dedicate the evening of Nov. 3 to breaking bread with loved ones.

While the online formality might sound silly to some, experts say a modern family needs all the help it can get when it comes to organizing dinner.

"Kids are participating in a ton of extracurricular activities these days," says pediatrician Elsie Taveras, lead researcher of the Harvard study of 14,355 youth. "You can imagine how that increased demand on our time is impacting the ability to get anyone together, let alone an entire family."

A survey released this week by Decima Research for the Holmes Group (marketer of Rival and Crock Pot slow cookers) indicates more than half of Canadians believe they don't have time to plan or execute a dinner event for family and friends. A full 30% cited dinner preparation as the most stressful element behind such a gathering.

A separate survey of Canadian women, released this week by Leger Marketing for Palm Canada, similarly found 21% of married mothers consider putting dinner on the table to be the most stressful activity in their day.

But Ms. Taveras's report, published in this month's issue of the journal Pediatrics, nonetheless calls for doctors to recommend family dinners as an ongoing health initiative.

"We understand the stresses and demands on people's time," Ms. Taveras says. "But our work has shown that if you eat family dinners more often, you have better diet quality and you're less likely to be overweight."

In Canada, there are even "coaches" available to get you started.

Lynn Fraser, founder of Families Are Worth It in Edmonton, says part of her job as a work-life balance coach is to teach families how to plan a meal. She covers everything from turning off the TV to changing "dinner logistics" (for example, eating dessert first) to offering conversation starters.

"It's really easy to put on a pot of frozen vegetables and boil them in the water," says Ms. Fraser, who is helping to promote National Family Dinner Night. "But when you're feeling stressed, even a simple, straightforward task like that is overwhelming."

Miriam Weinstein, author of the new book The Surprising Power of Family Meals: How Eating Together Makes Us Smarter, Stronger, Healthier and Happier, says people claiming to be "too busy" or "too stressed" to plan a family dinner need to re-evaluate their lifestyle.

"Schedules are a reflection of our priorities," explains Ms. Weinstein, a mother of two. "We brag now about how busy we are, how little time we have for anything, and it becomes self-fulfilling."

While she admits a "seamless, 90-minute dinner" is highly unrealistic, Ms. Weinstein believes it's within everyone's power -- and in every family's best interest -- to attempt regular sit-down suppers.

Pointing to a study released last month by the National Center on Addiction and Substance Abuse at Columbia University, she notes that family meals are even proven to curb risky behaviours among youth. Compared with teens who have five or more family dinners a week, the report found young people who have two or less family meals are three times likelier to try marijuana, 2 1/2 times likelier to smoke, more than 1 1/2 times likelier to drink alcohol and almost 40% less likely to receive A's and B's in school.
© National Post 2005
IP: q+9Z0cEhMCBTGO3P
BillygoatRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

Scully,

This is something that Mozz and our small group (at church) discussed at length yesterday. We find when we DO sit down to eat, it's on the sofa in front of the TV. So the 8 people (4 couples) in our group challenged each other to sit down together (with no TV!) and have an actual dinner at the dinner table at least THREE times this week. We're studying in our Sunday School class how much time TV robs from our lives...so this is our little "lab" to see what else we accomplish when we eliminate some of the TV watching our lives. We're finding our schedules increasingly busy, so the idea of having children is totally overwhelming to me right now. I can barely remember to feed my cats, how on earth am I going to keep track of a kid???

I'll let you know how it goes this week!

Andi
IP: v7v+O0cG//edopDK by Billygoat: Correct formatting
vittyRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

 

Most evening we do,  but it usually ends up in a row.   When you have a 18 year old who doesnt want to talk about what he done during the day and my husband who gets cross because he being unenthuiastic about his life, its not worth it.  

Highly over rated if you ask me, put the telly on and have something to talk about LOL

 
IP: ONcVAC4L+pFaCSJA
blondieRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

1.  We don't have children

2.  We were both single and ate alone for about 15 years.

3.  We come from the TV generation and watch while we eat (bad, bad) but we watch different channels.

Blondie
IP: iqwiRTIxNqGsmzhL
xjwmsRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

Good question......

We watch TV while we eat.  In the family room.

 
IP: nd79MfwNciNFJfd7
luna2Re: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

When my son lived at home we ate together....mostly in front of the television.  I'm sorry, but the two of us sitting at the table was boring.  My son never volunteered much information and I hated asking him a bunch of questions just to get him to talk to me.  At least watching tv, we'd discuss what was on.  LOL 
IP: 93wXr3MNckh778Zn
JHRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

I live alone, so I eat alone, and at very weird hours too 

Like Breakfast at 7am

Lunch at 10h30 am

Dinner at 3pm

Beer is only after 6pm
IP: mDOdm/BJcCz6ubgW
caligirlRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
We used to, but not so much now. Mostly it is in front of the TV, which I am not happy about, but that is the current habit. It depends on the time of year also- in the summer, we BBQ a lot, so we tend to spend more time outside away from TV. Right now, my husband's work hours make it nearly impossible more than 1 or 2 nights. That and all my scrapbook supplies have taken over the dining room table!
IP: X3ruKlKAKI6yhuIb
Lady LeeRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

looks around to see who else is here

Nope just me. Kitchen and living room all in one TV and table and computer all in one too

Therefore all of me eats all of my meal in the room

IP: bFIwWzi3vsLgGJB3 by Lady Lee: Correct formatting
BillygoatRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
looks around to see who else is here

Nope just me. Kitchen and living room all in one TV and table and computer all in one too

Therefore all of me eats all of my meal in the room

That makes just one less person to fight over the leftovers! 
IP: v7v+O0cG//edopDK
Lady LeeRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
That makes just one less person to fight over the leftovers

That means all the homemade bread is mine mine mine!!!!
IP: bFIwWzi3vsLgGJB3
Big DogRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
Just about everynight unless really odd circumstances we sit down and eat together, no radio, no TV.  I have read articles like this before and really believe in the concept.  Questions get asked about school, how things are going etc.  I really feel like it makes us bond as a family and there is something about breaking bread together that lends itself to open free communication, probably goes back to our caveman roots.
IP: jQM+/edzHNhA6TW5
BillygoatRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

Big Dog,

I agree - I think it's a healthy thing to do in most circumstances.  For me while growing up, eating dinner together was a very stressful event.  My parents always hounded me on what I wasn't doing, what I wasn't being...they spent a lot of time arguing.  It was basically the time to be critical of one another and duke it out.  My husband on the other hand grew up in a household where that was the one time during the day where criticizing wasn't allowed.  You could share your heart and mind and not worry about getting in trouble for it.  Thus it opened up the kids to share what they needed to mom and dad.  Thus, to this day, all three kids in his family are very close to their parents.  (My hubby comes from one of those families that I always envied growing up!)  It's the type of atmosphere I hope to give my child someday.

Realizing I might step on some toes here...

I think too many people think the "uncomfortableness" or "boringness" of eating dinner together, could be doing themselves and their families a disservice.  If it's uncomfortable, get over it.  Good things aren't always comfortable.  But they become comfortable in time with practice.  If it's boring, perhaps it's because the common ground isn't established to become interesting.  How is that fixed by continuing to not talk?  This is purely my opinion and...

...just food for thought...

Andi *ducking* 
IP: v7v+O0cG//edopDK
Big DogRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

Andi,

It is just such a natural time for you all to be together, I mean, it would be odd at say 8 o'clock to say, okay, let's all sit down and have a chat.  When you have kids I highly recommend it, and I agree, it needs to be peaceful, no fighting, etc., just a time to talk.  My parents were always very adament about it, that for however long it took us to eat we were going to talk together as a family, probably the only thing that allowed us to work through my rebelling against the borg yet remain on speaking terms.
IP: jQM+/edzHNhA6TW5
lonelysheepRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
Yes, I make it a point to eat w/my kids.  They are little now, but I'll try to keep doing so as they grow. 
IP: gtQ4kXGKMhFvDlIR
KaylenRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
We always do but the TV is always on
IP: 6FdYQRP7tBBrRr5H
MomofmanyRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
We eat together every night. Some times I fix the plates, some times I put bowls on the table. The kids all wait until I sit down, and then we eat. Even if we have things planned, we will eat later, just so we can all eat together. No TV, but some times I will have music playing in the backround.
IP: KELsYXgHMurZAaeb
jt stumblerRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?

Yes, its a must in our house.
IP: 22jmnhJl8VZWl9KO
ScullyRe: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
I think too many people think the "uncomfortableness" or "boringness" of eating dinner together, could be doing themselves and their families a disservice.  If it's uncomfortable, get over it.  Good things aren't always comfortable.  But they become comfortable in time with practice.  If it's boring, perhaps it's because the common ground isn't established to become interesting.  How is that fixed by continuing to not talk?

When Mr Scully and I first got married we had nice IKEA table that was comfortable for seating 4 adults.  It was very serviceable even when we had 3 small children.  Unfortunately, as the children grew (as they are apt to do) the table wasn't comfortable for all of us to sit together for meals, and we got out of the habit of eating together.  It was something that we ALL missed because we never got a chance to all of us sit down and discuss the day and upcoming plans and try to make some arrangements so we could accommodate everyone's wishes - and that was very stressful, even moreso than having a sit-down dinner every night.

About a year ago, we decided it was time to upgrade the table.  The new one seats 6-8 comfortably and has an extension feature that we can use when we have a big group of 10 or even 12.  At first, it was awkward starting conversations again, but we started playing board games and cards with the kids after dinner a couple of nights a week and that made a huge difference in everyone's comfort level and was a kind of conversation starter for those awkward moments.

That table and my crockpot were the best investments we've ever made in our family's well-being.
IP: NCiHJb2kWLhPPp2c
ShaniaRe: Re: Does Your Family Eat Dinner Together?
We always eat dinner together, it is the best part of the day for our family. My husband and myself were raised with family dinners every night at 5pm sharp, filled with laughing and telling stories of the days events, then came the dishes (NO DISHWASHER FOR US), but it really set a way with us both, our family loves to sit down at 5pm..(kept that time) and enjoy being together...........Oh yeah there was always the BIG SUNDAY DINNER AFTER CHURCH...............until the witnesses came along and ruined that.............then it was no breakfast, meetings, then service with a quick drive thru to McDs...............thats how our sunday was after 1975
IP: BheslLdNS9C0LgSX by Shania: Correct formatting