MemberPostViewed: times
bestyThe real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...


Think about it. 99% of JW's have no idea whats allowed and whats banned - too complex.

So most JW's tick the I accept nothing box. This from an HLC member I spoke with some time back. Just to be on the 'safe' side, ironically.

Anyway imagine the number of dead JW's there would be if this was allowed to run its course.

So IMHO part of the HLC raison d'etre is to make sure JW's take the blood fractions they are 'allowed'.

Thoughts?

IP: ilHWeifFdbQB/vRo
CasperRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

Sounds possible....

When my second husband was in the hospital, the HLC was called in. They decided to wait until his blood count got to a ridiculously low level... and then they would arrange for him to be given something. I have no idea now what it even was. Fortunately his count stabilized and he didn't need what they were going to... "OK"... for him to have.

So, yeah they had something in the works.

Cas

IP: gIRE2MDkL8LulYyY by Casper: Correct formatting
AudeSapereRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
Besty wrote: So most JW's tick the I accept nothing box. This from an HLC member I spoke with some time back. Just to be on the 'safe' side, ironically.

I discussed the options cited on the AMD with my very strict jw friend before surgery about 10 years ago.  She was adamant that it was OK to take certain factions and tried to encourage me to do the same.

I ticked 'accept nothing' with the reasoning that if I would refuse to donate to the cause on religious grounds, it would be wrong to accept blood - even in fraction form.

Silly me.

-Aude.

PS: Fortunately, mostly because of my refusal to accept blood, my surgeon and I discussed various surgical approaches and no blood was needed.

IP: V0nnklS2QRV6E4rT
willylomanRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

An HLC member went to work at a hospital after several months of consulting with them on setting up their "bloodless surgery" center. He became an adminstrator at the hospital, in charge of that program. This was a full-time paid position. This scenario is not uncommon these days. One of his jobs was to serve as the liaison between the hospital and the HLC members, all of whom were people he knew and had worked with when he was on the area HLC.

His job at the hospital was exactly the same as it was when he was on the HLC: to advise JW patients as to what their options were in a surgical situation. He was extremely well-versed on the Society's "present truth" with respect to blood use, including fractions, cell savers, the use of EPO and other drugs, etc.

Every morning he'd review the hospital census report (which includes a notation on the patient's religious preference) and visit every single dub who was in the hospital (and especially those in for surgery). He would introduce himself and make sure they knew he was a dub elder and former HLC member, and then review all the options that were "approved" by the WTS.

He said that 98% of the dubs he saw "had no idea" what the current JW teaching was on blood and were usually surprised (and greatly relieved) when he ticked off all the available options. Almost every one of them then signed consent forms allowing the use of alternate medical management that included the use of fractions and other treatments.

This made the doctors enormously happy, of course. It made the hospital happy because it was a new "profit center" for them (they marketed this to the JW Community extensively). It made the dub patients happy, too, because nobody died. He was especially happy in the Trauma Center/Emergency Room because he was able to give the surgeons wiggle room when a dub was scraped off the highway and presented with heavy blood loss.

I would say you are exactly correct: His job was to make sure JWs take blood (or some fraction thereof, as allowed by "Mother"). And he was taught that through his years of work on the HLC, where he performed exactly the same work without pay.

Not that there's anything wrong with that, of course. But it speaks volumes about the extent to which this whole blood thing is truly "up to each individual's bible trained conscience," as the dub organization would have you believe.

IP: ztyxVMuACm7RLTez
bestyRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
He said that 98% of the dubs he saw "had no idea" what the current JW teaching was on blood

yep - that seems to be the consensus - the JW's are baffled by their own beliefs

Like Aude says - its hypocritical to take but not donate - I reckon a lot of true believers feel that way. My brother does for one.

IP: ilHWeifFdbQB/vRo
nicolaouRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
You may be onto something Paul. http://www.jehovahs-witness.com/16/125130/1.ashx
IP: RIoRLiMNEmzIBVuQ
5goRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
Honestly I would have to say no. I know some HLC brothers that cringe at blood fractions and have zero problem with a no blood fraction stand even to the death.
IP: U+3anTbh9OjaDDH+
willylomanRe: Re: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
I know some HLC brothers that cringe at blood fractions and have zero problem with a no blood fraction stand even to the death.

The key word there is "some." At a conference I attended on advances in bloodless surgery, conducted by a dub elder hospital administrator, attended only by invited JW elders and their wives, the guy finished and then asked for a show of hands. He wanted to know, given everything that had just been explained about the Society's current position on blood and transfusions, how many in the audience would take advantage of all the options. At first it appeared the entire audience held up hands. then he asked, "Is there anyone who would not?" Two people raised their hands. The look on their faces told me they were silently condemining everyone else in the room!

Also: In some rural areas, there are no HLC guys like the elder I've been talking about in this thread. In many cities and suburbs, there are. Wherever an HLC has at least one guy who has some education and any kind of medical background and/or reads and understands the Society's current doctrines, most of the others generally bow to his authority on such matters. So, like many other JW perceptions, it depends on where you live.

IP: ztyxVMuACm7RLTez
White DoveRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
Donate? Blood? What? Please explain this to me.
IP: JAA1/rinyOqM6JLf
bestyRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
Some more thoughtful or old school JW's won't accept any blood products as they feel it would be hypocritical to make use of a blood supply that they are forbidden from donating back into.
IP: qrs+0rAydFr+zlj7
WTWizardRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

I feel that the HLC is there to make sure that witlesses in the hospital do not get out free from the hounders.  Also, they make sure they do not get banned blood products without getting an extra hard time.

For instance, a person who needs blood will not be allowed to make the decision to take the blood in peace.  Usually, what happens is the Hounder Committee will make sure they get guilted out of taking the blood, losing precious time in which either blood or an alternative could have been effectively taken and a good outcome accomplished.  They end up suffering needlessly as a result.

IP: avsGxrusH2y5goKj
BluesBrotherRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

The dubs that I know do not want any blood products at all. They equate them with other diseases and just dont want to take any. Their own life in this system is not so important.

But they are mainly "old school" . I have not spoken with younger ones..Did I not read when the poor girl from Telford (who had given birth to twins) was dying, the HLC tried to get the doctors to use fractions to try and save her?

IP: 6V/ki0mr23JCTLkb
Witness 007Re: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
Funny we need these H.L.C "Rabbi's" to explain this complex and baffling blood doctrine to sick Witnesses, like some type of KGB unit!  The most blood-guilty men in the world are the Elders on the H.L.C.  Shame on them all!
IP: AKSzSh+ak74q0eUq
Sam BeliRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

The HLC is present to impose the conscience of the GB on the ill JW who
is between the sheets.  For "old school" JWs this means helping them
understand what "fractions" they may take.

For JWs who want to exercise their own conscience the HLC's job becomes
the enforcer, policeman or as some medical staffs have observed, they
are the Gestapo of the JW world in the hospital.  This Gestapo role is not
without justification to the JW mindset.  More than a few JWs will accept
forbidden blood components when out of sight of prying eyes.  Why do
you think that JW elders and "strong" family members want someone with
the patient at all times?

IP: B/dh+ep73Cj65Is7
White DoveRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

So, JW's are still forbidden from donating blood. Gotcha. But I'm confused about how the HLC ever gets wind of the JW in the hospital? Aside from the obvious calling the elders when someone is in the hospital, isn't there ever a time when the ill one doesn't want them there? Isn't that the time when you can sneek blood if you need it? How do they know your condition without reading your chart? That is confidential, right? Where do hospital ethics prevent others from reading your records? Where is the confidentiality?

I could, in all honesty, get away with taking blood and no one being the wiser. All I would have to do is explain that any treatment is confidential because of the HLC, and that I don't want them there interfering. If questioned by elders later on why I didn't want the HLC involved, I would say that it's confidential. It would be a legal thing. If they tried a JC with me, I'd get a lawyer involved.

Does the HLC have access to my records? Am I way off on all of this?

 

IP: JAA1/rinyOqM6JLf
PubsingerRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

I've held that view ever since I left.

I'm sure I've posted it on here somewhere

IP: sWIaiUMXqib/fbwi
willylomanRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
But I'm confused about how the HLC ever gets wind of the JW in the hospital? That is confidential, right? Where do hospital ethics prevent others from reading your records?

Patients are formally admitted to hospitals by way of filling out forms. On these forms is a space to note the patient's religious preference. A daily "census" (listing every patient who is in the hospital) is produced for in-hospital use by staff. Clergy are allowed to look at the census so they can visit their parishioners/congregants who are ill. Dubs, like all other religions, have an organized arrangement whereby assigned personnel visit the local hospital and review the census, just as all other religious groups do.

Confidentiality is on you. If you don't select a religious preference, they will list you as having none (and some dubs actually do this to avoid scrutiny). The census is not public information. To view it, you have to be authorized. Hospitals view clergy as authorized.

Sometimes church members (including dubs) will show up at the hospital to see a patient, having learned they are there through the gossip network. In those cases, the staff will usually come in to your room, tell you that you have a visitor and who it is, and ask if you want to see them.

 

IP: ztyxVMuACm7RLTez
MissingLinkRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...
Wow. I never considered that.  You're probably right.  They're there to push the people as far as they need to, but also make sure they don't kill off too many who don't understand the rules.
IP: xowqT3PfvHIXtDNt
quietlyleavingRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

Besty

I think so too

ql

IP: zDwseFmDRwIFDSuV
BalsamRe: The real purpose of the HLC is to make sure JW's take blood...

In 2001 prior to anything being know about blood fractions the HLC was basically useless to us through they were there at the hospital with us when our son was injured in an car accident.  He had no suggestions and later I learned that some of the witnesses (2) had been approved to hemopure an experimental blood substitute new developed.  The HLC knew nothing of it and our son died.  I was angry and frustrated when I began to really look at the new developing teachings about the use of fractions. 

I hate the SOB governing body for their ignorance, and this stupid no blood transfusion rule they continue to support.  My ex husband told our son that now they can store and use their own blood.  So far as I know that is still forbidden unless something has changed in the very recient guildlines. 

Ruth

IP: 1ZyZzOvE9nZqdaUx