MemberPost
In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Kenneson on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by badboy on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Gill on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by greendawn on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by isthisit on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Hellrider on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by isthisit on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by carla on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by fullofdoubtnow on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Gilberto on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by barry on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by diamondblue1974 on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by funkyderek on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by JWdaughter on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by diamondblue1974 on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by badboy on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by diamondblue1974 on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by JWdaughter on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by diamondblue1974 on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by nelly136 on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by SirNose586 on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by JWdaughter on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by uwishufish on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by garybuss on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by diamondblue1974 on

Joe GrundyRe: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion


This could be very interesting.

In my humble (and layman's) opinion:

1.  WTBTS/the dubs could not be a party to the litigation - it would have to be the woman concerned as sole plaintiff

2.  The medical authorities would have an unassailable defence against a suit for assault because they were acting in accordance with a court order

3.  Possible suit against the medical authorities for misrepresentation/negligence in collecting and presenting the evidence to the court when applying for the order?  Difficult to prove, i would have thought.

4.  If the legal position in Eire is the same as in UK, individual judges etc. cannot be sued for their judicial decisions

5.  Possibly an action in a higher court (or Eurpean Court) for breach of the woman's human rights under ECHR?  Possible, but on what basis could she ask for damages/compensation?  And the breach has now finished if it existed at all so she couldn't sue for an order to desist (ceriatori?)

6.  I don't know anything about the Legal Aid system in Eire, but suspect she may have difficulty in getting funding.

7.  I can't see that WTBTS would fund her.  The publicity surrounding this case could, I suspect, be enough to outweigh the JW's efforts in door-to-door work for years to come.

 

IP: IAMD9CJRv47BRVzi

Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by isthisit on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Joe Grundy on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusionw by isthisit on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Joe Grundy on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by sspo on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by DannyHaszard on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by DannyHaszard on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by badboy on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Mulan on
Re: Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by valkyrie on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by DannyHaszard on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Gill on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by DannyHaszard on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by moshe on
Re: In Ireland, JW's may sue over blood transfusion by Gill on