MemberPost

blondieGoverning Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority?

In the Bible in discussing the debacle about circumcision in the early Christian community, the WTS states about what they consider the GB:

w98
11/1 p. 5 How to Solve Problems Peacefully

After a Scriptural discussion, the apostles and Jerusalem elders came "to a unanimous accord" not to burden uncircumcised believers unnecessarily but to admonish them "to keep abstaining from things sacrificed to idols and from blood and from things strangled and from fornication."

Yet former Governing Body member Raymond Franz in his book Crisis of Conscience reveals how a virtual coup against third president Nathan Knorr resulted in a new process for determining doctrine, a two-thirds majority vote of the Governing Body now being required for any doctrinal change to take place.

I notice that there is conveniently nothing in the WTS publications about this (if there is, tell me where, please).

I have known for some through Bethel contacts that this was true. It is noteworthy that nothing appears in writing since it would make people wonder. Why did the 1st century GB do things unanimously and the current GB only needs a 2/3 vote. I do know that elder bodies are supposed to be nominally unanimous in their selections of elders and MS.

I guess the other 1/3 weren't plugged into the holy spirit that day.

Blondie
IP: pFiPjYKdt/7Wyjum by blondie: Correct formatting

Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by freedom96 on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by Pistoff on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by gumby on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by JeffT on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by Gadget on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by TheOldHippie on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by blondie on
Re: Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by TheOldHippie on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by TheOldHippie on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by hooberus on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by obiwan on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by plmkrzy on
Re: Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by TheOldHippie on
queRe: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by wannaexit on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by shotgun on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by blondie on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by mizpah on
Re: Governing Body--Unanimous or Two-Thirds Majority? by blondie on